Meta just told Canada's Senate that complying with Bill C-22 and still offering end-to-end encrypted services is "not technically feasible," and that it would "consider" pulling encrypted services from Canada if the bill passes as is.
Signal says it would leave too. So what does the bill actually do?
• Part 2 lets the Public Safety Minister issue orders requiring providers to build capabilities for police and intelligence access
• OpenMedia describes those orders as secret and gagged
• OpenMedia reported on June 16 that the government blocked committee debate on Part 2
• Signal's Udbhav Tiwari said Signal would not compromise user security to stay in Canada
• Minister Gary Anandasangaree has said the bill will be amended to clarify that breaching encryption is not allowed, and his ministry "categorically rejected" claims it enables surveillance
Meta's Canadian policy head Rachel Curran says those amendments do not go far enough to protect encrypted data.
If nothing in the bill breaks encryption, why did the government block committee debate on the one part that gives a minister the power to order the access built? And why are Signal and Meta talking about leaving rather than building it? We should all be watching this closely.
Amanda Seales says she ended things with her Grenadian boyfriend after his family started treating her like an ATM. She says his uncle asked her to buy him a truck or van for a business and later denied asking for money, and the mother of his children demanded money while keeping Seales from seeing the kids and posting her picture on WhatsApp. Her biggest issue was that he never told them to back off. "I can't be quiet about this," she said, warning everyone in Grenada about who they are dealing with.