I wasn't raised as isolated as the amish, but still sufficiently isolated that I had significant culture shock upon entering the world.
The hardest part about this was that people couldn't understand my unfamiliarity. If I'd moved from a foreign country, I'd have an accent or look different and people would immediately understand if I didn't know who Brittney Spears was. But I didn't - I grew up in the same town, and I spoke the same language, so there was this intense isolation on a meta level where my foreignness itself was a shock to others, where people would talk to me as though I should understand all these cultural references, and I would feel intensely awkward when I didn't, and I didn't know how to succinctly explain to them the nature of my upbringing in a way that would let them know how to relate to me.