Essayist. Satirist. Hacker. Confessions from the people running the systems you live with. Essays, films and commentary on tech, power and being human.
I am the Provost of a great institution. A university. Oxford, Cambridge, Harvard. It does not matter which one anymore, and that is the first thing I will confess.
We did not inherit the word rigor. We built it. For 900 years the university was the place that knew how to know. We built the method for checking whether a thing is true, and the whole world borrowed it.
This year we could not run a plagiarism check on our own professor.
Here is the product we still sell. We take an 18-year-old and hold her to the standard. Cite every source. Run it through the software. One borrowed sentence is an offense with a hearing.
The rigor is for her. We stopped running it on ourselves.
She pays for the standard. She borrows to pay for it. The debt outlives the knowledge.
The tuition goes up every year. The degree buys less every year. We print those two numbers in separate documents. They never meet.
The degree used to open the door. Now it is the fee for standing near the door. She graduates owing us, into a market that wants the credential and does not want her.
Cambridge. We gave a man a professorship. We did not run the nine-second check we make every first-year run. Strangers ran it, for free, on their own time. They found pages of his thesis that matched an older one. A journal added the missing citations two years late.
The basic task. Read the sources. Confirm they are his. We taught the world that task. We skipped it in our own building.
A reporter read the work all the way through. Which was more than we had done.
He asked us questions. We answered with a libel firm. The story got pulled.
Then the professor reported the reporter to the police. The police said it should have been screened out.
Cambridge opened an investigation this month. He resigned before we could finish it. He says he is not a fantasist. We say nothing. Saying nothing is accredited.
Washington. Vetting a speaker is a first-week assignment. Read the public record. Decide.
We invited the Twitch streamer Hasan Piker to lecture. Two schools sponsored it. $10 a head. We did not do the first-week assignment.
Then the phones rang, and we discovered the invitation lacked "rigor." Rigor has excellent timing. It shows up exactly when the backlash does, and never before.
We hold her to the standard. Every source. Every claim. And, quietly, every conclusion.
She learns the fastest lesson we teach. The safe answer is the one we already hold. Agreement is graded. Deviation is a conversation with someone in an office.
We call the result critical thinking. It is the other thing. The phrase tests well on the campus tour.
We grade the 18-year-old's conclusions to the decimal. We graded our own professor's sources not at all. The rigor was always pointed at the student. Never at us.
Understand how far this goes. We are the institution that grades the exam. We would not pass it now. We have never sat it.
We taught the world to check its work. The world checks ours now. For free.
Nobody grades the grader.
We stopped being the standard.
We kept the crest. And the tuition. The tuition is the one number here that never fell.