A more balanced take on $MU earnings and feedback from Wells' Rocha:
"MU: As the above picture indicates, a bit of a nothing burger in terms of giving investors meat to sink their teeth into. That was the headline point of feedback from most yesterday afternoon and last night. The tactical trade was/is playing the expected pending buyback announcement which MU can commence in December, after anniversary-ing a CHIPS deadline. The structural trade is playing the re-rate on margin stability and increase in visibility/commits from the SCAs. Yesterday didn’t give either camp much incremental to work with. MU effectively sounds good on FCF generation, they have now for a while frankly, but didn’t bite the buyback biting and so we’re now in a 3mo holding pattern until the NovQ print. On the structural side, there are now 26 SCAs up 63% QoQ with some extending out to 2031 and with S/D imbalance into C28. A little incremental for both camps, but again nothing to run home about relative to elevated buy side expectations. Bears were and are nitpicking at the GM% guiding being down QoQ% and margins broadly underwhelming relative to very heightened expects. One interesting point that came up in my convos is the suggestion that bit growth slows while Capex is set to inflect higher, and trying to square both of those impacts. There were rumblings/speculation that Idaho could pull-forward from my investor convos into the print, and now with this bits vs capex dynamic, I suspect that the prospect of supply hitting early becomes a bigger conversation point in the investor debate/narrative. The offset here is the effect of more mix-shift to HBM from conventional DRAM consuming more bit supply and generally the long equipment lead times. If we start to hear rumblings of DRAM pull-ins over the next few weeks and month, the question to me is whether that will be treated as a positive (rev-rec sooner) or negative (inevitable impact on pricing) for MU. For now, my sense is that $MU will sadly get the NVDA treatment from the HF crowd and be treated as a funding short – I definitely got some of that feedback last night."