가입 후 초대 링크를 공유하면 동영상 재생 및 초대 보상을 받을 수 있습니다.

Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
CFR senior fellow. Views are my own. Writes on sovereign debt, trade, fx reserves and capital flows.
가입 May 2016
1.1K 팔로잉 중    161.1K 팬
a) It is true that the CNY has never been so strong that Chinese exports systematically under-perform global trade b) that doesn't mean that the CNY doesn't have an impact on trade flows/ net exports -- China's surplus tends to expand when exports outperform global trade, while being more or less constant when exports growth with global trade all ears if someone has a credible aggregate overcapacity variable and wants to throw that into a standard trade regression ... but the easy way to think of it is that Chinese overcapacity stays at home when the CNY is strong and flows to the world when the CNY is weak this chart, incidentally, fully supports the IMF's work showing a 10 pp move in the RER changes net exports by about 1.5 pp v baseline
더 보기
There is a clear asymmetry at play. The long term correlation is very low. What do I mean? Look at right side of the graph: the currency declined and exports grew above trend. That makes sense and it's observable. Now look at the left side: the currency grew significantly more expensive but exports kept growing on trend. This tells is two key things. First, there is a clear asymmetry in how Chinese trade responds to changes in the value of the RMB. Just because exports increase when the currency declined, do not expect exports to decline (or though not pictured here imports to increase). Second, there are clearly missing variables that would help explain why we are seeing the results we are seeing. As a simple example, the mass of Chinese over capacity is playing a significant role in boosting exports. This concept would be especially true considering imports. In short, do not expect a symmetric bounce in imports
더 보기