가입 후 초대 링크를 공유하면 동영상 재생 및 초대 보상을 받을 수 있습니다.

Gary Spedding
@GarySpedding
Human rights & conflict transformation advocacy in solidarity with both 🇵🇸 & 🇦🇲. Can also be found fighting antisemitism. Contact: Gary@gary-spedding.com
가입 July 2011
2.7K 팔로잉 중    15.4K 팬
Okay, let's debunk this hasbara from @OurFightUk: Claiming that Haifa is a shining model of seamless Arab-Jewish integration—where restaurants “jostle,” religions are equally represented, and universities are fully multicultural—whitewashes a reality of structural inequality, second-class citizenship, and recurring racism directed at Palestinian citizens of Israel. I was in Haifa last year. It is indeed one of Israel’s more mixed cities. Public spaces are relatively open compared with many other places in Israel, Arabic is heard on the streets more than in Tel Aviv or West Jerusalem, and universities have significant Arab enrollment. But that is about it when it comes to the romanticising of Haifa. The city is beautiful and has a rich history. There is art, culture, poetry, gardens, wonderful beaches and iconic scenery. However, Palestinian neighborhoods in Haifa have long faced underinvestment, poorer planning, substandard services, and higher poverty. These structural disparities shed light on the limits to the claims of coexistence and integration. All one need do is engage directly with Palestinian citizens of Israel in Haifa to get a full understanding of the complexities of their existence. Speak to people like Jafar Farah of the Mossawa Center and you'll find a far more nuanced perspective. Also listen to Tom Mehager of @AdalahCenter when he describes this succinctly: “The Israeli idea of coexistence is about a majority and a minority – the strong and the weak. Coexistence is not equality. Speaking the same language and eating hummus together doesn’t mean Jews and Arabs are equal.” Here is a taste of just some of the ongoing issues: discriminatory budgeting (Arab-directed programs cut more sharply), housing discrimination and gentrification that erodes remaining Palestinian presence and heritage (including sales of Absentee Property homes from the 1948 expulsions as luxury real estate), unequal protective infrastructure, and restrictions on Arabic signage and cultural expression. Palestinian citizens of Israel in Haifa often have to hide their culture, cannot display symbols and emblems representing themselves as Palestinians, and can face racialised discrimination in various settings at any time without and recourse. Just a few months ago, in a May 2026 Haifa City Council meeting, Palestinian council member Sally Abed spoke in Arabic while raising the freezing of enforcement against Arabic signage. In response, a fellow council member, Yaniv Ben-Shoshan, shouted at her to “Go to Gaza.” Multiple other council members told Sally openly that Haifa was not Arab, but Jewish. Listen to people like Diana Buttu (Palestinian citizen living in Haifa) has described the situation bluntly: “For Palestinians it is no coexistence, but sub-existence… so long as you identify as an Israeli who ‘happens’ to speak Arabic, you are tolerated. But once your Palestinian identity surfaces, you run into all kinds of discriminatory laws.” Ignoring these documented inequalities, the routine treatment of Arabic and Palestinian identity as provocations, and the testimony of the very Palestinian citizens and Haifa-based NGOs (Mossawa, Adalah, etc.) who live it, should tell us everything we need to know about the position @OurFightUk is promoting and their claims that Haifa is a beacon of coexistence. The reality in Haifa is one that is not of geniine equality or true Jewish-Arab partnership. These slogans you are using are not a legitimate argument against the termination of the twinning agreement.
더 보기