The narrative:
HEaT sHiElD TiLEs ArE a DeAd EnD
The reality:
SpaceX can trade off refurbishment costs against landing odds.
If the starship that right now remains a floating contemporary art piece on the surface of the Indian Ocean had instead been brought back to the tower, refilled and launched again and then incinerated on re-entry, that alone would have reduced prospective cost per kg to orbit by 45% relative to an expendable Starship top stage, and by 58% compared to Falcon 9's estimated costs.