Last wk, $NVDA CEO resigned, $NBIS cut forecast, $SFTBY had $3.7B power gen equipment write-down. SOX +8.1%, Nas +2.3%, S&P +2.5%, anyway. When after sharp decline, mkts rally despite bad news, next leg higher has probably started whether a new bull or continuing bear mkt.
During the 2.5 year meltdown after the internet bubble, using a 5% gain as the minimum for an S&P rally and the same dates for the measurements below:
-S&P rallied 7 times avg 14% each while losing 49%
-Nasdaq rallied 7 times avg 25% each while losing 78%
-SOX rallied 7 times avg 28% each while losing 83%
-these rallies on average each lasted for 2 months
This is why I try to catch fundamental inflection points, both near-term tops and bottoms, and am not as focused on whether it is THE TOP or THE BOTTOM. The rallies and declines can be vicious in either case and the difference can only be known in hindsight. While I personally do not think we have seen THE TOP due to the recent advent of Agentic AI, the headwinds have been building since mid-year.
One major bearish macro development last week is economic data supported more aggressive rate hikes. Bond yields went up 33-20 bps across the 2-30 year yield curve despite the 2% drop in oil prices.
Recapping the current AI trade and recent developments
6/22 to 7/29: (I warned on 6/20 of an AI “speed bump”)
AI cost controls to Situational Awareness (SA) crisis
SOX Index -29%, Nasdaq -7%, SPX -2%
7/29-10/6: (posted 7/29 “short-term bottom today”)
Rally from oversold levels post SA resolution
SOX +27%, Nasdaq +13%, SPX +7%
10/6-11/5 (10/4 “pushback on DCs could get worse”)
Both parties agree on AI DC delays prior to mid-terms
SOX -32%, Nasdaq -12%, SPX -6%,
11/5-11/13
Relief rally from oversold levels post mid-terms
SOX +13%, Nasdaq +3%, SPX +3%,
AI rally despite Nvidia, Nebius, Softbank news
Nvida earnings on Tuesday is the next major event.
Bullish Points
1) At GTC Berlin on October 21st, Nvidia reiterated their guidance of growing CY27 revenues at 70% due to supply constraints with demand over 100%.
2) CY27 PE is only 11x vs S&P at 18x and peers AVGO at 17x and AMD at 30x.
3) There was “blood in the streets.” Despite the stock having already declined 37% from its peak on 10/6 to its opening price on Thursday 11/12 the day generational CEO Jensen resigned, at least 11 Wall Street analysts downgraded the stock.
4) From a technical standpoint, the stock rallied 10% from its opening price to close down just 4% that day. It is still up 8% from that opening price even after its decline on Friday.
5) There is also the possibility that Jensen returns to Nvidia.
Bearish Points
1) A generational CEO is gone. Colette Kress, the CFO since 2013 and one of the best in the business, is the interim CEO. She was the reason there was not even more circular financing. All current and future deals will be evaluated more closely.
2) While this is good for Nvidia’s balance sheet and resiliency during the next downturn, it will lower their CY27 revenue growth from the neo-clouds (potentially ~20% of revs.) Having said that, their main neo-cloud driver for CY27 is $SPCX and their growth could actually be helped by less competition.
3) 38% of Nvidia revs came from outside of the US last quarter with some portion at risk given tighter export controls following the purported Chinese spy scandal.
4) 8.2% of revenues from China (including Hong Kong) and 1.3% from other geographies is particularly at risk from more severe export controls.
5) GTC Berlin comment came before the mid-term election results where only one of the 40+ county ballot initiatives to curtail datacenters did not pass and pro-moratorium governors were elected
I believe that Colette, being fiscally prudent, will use 1) the mid-terms results, 2) likely tightening of export controls and 3) less marginal neo-cloud demand, to reduce forward expectations including potentially pulling the annual guidance. Prior to last quarter they had just given quarterly guidance and never given annual guidance which I believe was more prudent given the inherent cyclicality of the semiconductor business.
I believe the stock is likely to be up on Wednesday in reaction to earnings guidance being the second clearing event following the resignation of generational CEO Jensen. Even if the stock drops in reaction to earnings, I believe the stock saw its near-term low on Thursday when blood was everywhere.
The time to be bearish on semiconductors was as early as late June on companies trying to control token costs or at the latest in October when both political parties which couldn’t agree on anything agreed on datacenter pushbacks. I believe that in the near-term, a long position in Nvidia paired with related shorts in neo-clouds and the financing chain makes sense.
$ANT IPO on Thursday is other major event this week.
With the Jensen resignation, the most vocal champion of open-source is now gone. As a result, both Anthropic and OpenAI became more valuable given their potential for regulatory capture. At a $1.5 trillion IPO valuation which would be 28x CY26 revs of $54B, Anthropic would be attractively priced vs $SPCX at 38x and $PLTR at 46x. A strong debut by the stock of Anthropic would be a nice boost for the AI ecosystem.
Best of luck during another eventful week.
顯示更多