註冊並分享邀請連結,可獲得影片播放與邀請獎勵。

Alex Priou
@alexpriou
Roubos Sabbatical Scholar @BensonCenter & Professor of Political Philosophy @uaustinorg | Specialist in the most weighty matters and the one thing needful
加入 August 2013
1.3K 正在關注    9.7K 粉絲
Here's the dilemma (for the billionth time): 1) Esoteric writing is an extremely well documented historical fact. 2) Reading esoterically risks arbitrariness. The solution is not to reject reading this way. That's an abdication of the historiographer's responsibility. The challenge must be accepted. That said, Phil is simply wrong about Strauss. There is no "magic decoder ring" nonsense. Strauss was constantly revising his readings, both in writing and in private. He did not believe reading could be reduced to a method, to say nothing of a "ring" (whatever that means…). Strauss is not beyond criticism, and many of his students have departed from him. But Phil's path is misleading and avoids the very real challenge Strauss has placed before us. The solution has to involve rigorous reading, re-reading, and debate. But we cannot keep our heads in the sand and pretend esoteric writing is not a real phenomenon.
顯示更多
0
15
192
14
轉發到社區