X ALGORITHM ANALYSIS 👀
When you tag or reply to someone on X, the open source code has a list of reasons the notification never reaches them. And the newest one is muted words (so small accounts: when you tag someone, write a clean, original post)
tl;dr:
- in X's Nov 19 release, muted words showed up in its notification code
- your post has a word they muted: no notification
- muted "only from people I don't follow" and they follow you: it gets through
- they only allow mentions from people they follow: no notification
- a spam or duplicate label on your post: no notification, for anyone
- the same rules cover mentions and replies
Lesson learned: when you tag someone, write a real, original post with no junk in it
Full details:
- What's new
X added muted words to the rules that decide if a mention or reply notifies someone.
If your post contains a word they muted for notifications, the notification is dropped.
Most people have probably seen this in the app already. What's new is that it's now in the open source code, so we can see exactly how it works.
(I check the open source algo daily with Claude and share updates with you)
- The follow exception
When you mute a word on X, you can pick "only from people I don't follow".
If they picked that and they follow you, your notification still gets through. If they don't follow you, it doesn't.
One more reason your regulars matter.
- The other ways a tag goes nowhere
They set mentions to "only people I follow" and they don't follow you. Dropped.
Your post has a duplicate content or spam label. Dropped, for everyone.
They have the quality filter on and don't follow you: a post labeled abusive, with an untrusted link, or as a duplicate mention or spammy reply is dropped too.
- What you won't see
Your post still goes up. Only the ping is dropped.
Nothing in this code tells you it happened. So a tag that "got ignored" may simply never have arrived.
- My take
Tagging someone only works if the post you tag them in is clean.
Copy-paste the same reply everywhere, add a junk link, or stuff it with the words people mute, and the person you wanted to reach never hears about it.
X changed how it pays creators.
Since September 8, the old Creator Revenue Sharing program has been replaced by an "Original Content Rewards" program.
What counts: posts that reflect your own voice, perspective, expertise or creativity, including meaningful transformations of existing posts.
What doesn't: reuploads, and posts that are explicit, misleading or break the rules.
In plain terms: reposting someone else's viral clip used to be a way to farm payouts. Now it isn't supposed to be.
For creators who post their own analysis, this is good news. For accounts built on reposts, it's a problem.
Has your feed changed since September?
"X has become a much more powerful force in driving tech investor sentiment over the past few years. Honestly, besides Bloomberg, it’s my most important resource. I literally started a new section of my daily email a few weeks ago called SchilskyX where I screenshot and respond to Tweets. It’s that important. One important issue to note: the FinTwit community of influencers is VERY small. We’re talking less than 50 people that drive a preponderance of sentiment. Most investors and sell siders can’t tweet – so only a small number of FinTwit influencers with any sort of respectability drive much of the debate." - JPMorgan's Mark Schilsky