The UK government just lost its bid to keep secret that it served Apple with an order over encrypted iCloud data, and the tribunal called its national security argument "fanciful".
So why was a government fighting so hard to avoid saying it out loud?
• The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the Home Office's claim that confirming the order would damage national security
• It noted earlier official disclosures had already made the order's existence widely known
• In April 2025 the same tribunal refused to keep even the bare details of Apple's challenge secret
• The order's technical requirements, scope and access method are still not public
• A government spokesman says the order "simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so", and that Apple has been helping police and intelligence agencies for several years
Apple has already pulled its Advanced Data Protection option for new UK users. Read plainly, "maintain the ability" points to Apple being able to get in, and encryption that Apple can open on demand is not really end-to-end.
Whether the order is even lawful is still undecided, and what it demands is not public.