註冊並分享邀請連結,可獲得影片播放與邀請獎勵。

Vivi
@vivilinsv
Silicon Valley Correspondent @californiapost @nypost| People, AI, money & power | ex @Reuters TV & @ftchinese columnist | Signal: Vivilinsv.88 |Views are my own
加入 December 2013
9.1K 正在關注    31.1K 粉絲
Be careful who you let write your biography. Jensen Huang gave Stephen Witt extraordinary access to his life, his company and the people around him. Now that Jensen is down, here comes the character takedown. There’s a Chinese expression for this: 落井下石. Throwing stones at someone who has already fallen into a well. And some of the “evidence” here? Honestly - excuse me?! My cats have better logical thinking than this! Jensen leaves a waitress a $1,000 tip at Denny’s. Witt explicitly acknowledges that Jensen didn’t make a show of it. In fact, Witt had to track down the waitress to find out how much he’d left. Yet somehow, this becomes part of an argument that Jensen’s humility was an act, performed to flatter himself. Excuse me?! How do we get from a generous tip, quietly given, to that conclusion? Is Witt jealous that Jensen did not tip him instead? You can report what someone did. You cannot read his mind. Where is the evidence that helping this waitress was secretly an exercise in self-admiration? Then there’s the leadership argument. Jensen is stubborn. He insists he’s right. But persistence and conviction are hardly surprising qualities in someone who built Nvidia. When judging those qualities, surely it matters whether his decisions actually proved correct. Criticize the shouting. Question how he treats employees. Those are fair subjects. But being difficult to persuade does not, by itself, prove that someone’s judgment is bad. Do we really need to explain that leadership sometimes means sticking with a decision other people doubt? What bothers me is the eagerness to reinterpret everything through the worst possible lens. Even a quiet act of generosity becomes suspect. Having grown up in China, I find that way of arguing uncomfortably familiar. It has the flavor of a Cultural Revolution denunciation: once someone falls, even the good things must be recast as evidence against him. Of course a biographer doesn’t owe his subject flattering coverage. Access doesn’t buy loyalty. But readers are still entitled to evidence that supports the conclusions. Jensen has mistakes to answer for. That doesn’t make every hostile interpretation of his character convincing. To me, this column reveals more about the author’s judgment than Jensen’s character. And yes, character matters. Especially when things are difficult and when someone is down. Just look at the photo they chose for Jensen - hey, Halloween is over!
顯示更多
0
43
650
75
轉發到社區