Register and share your invite link to earn from video plays and referrals.

Search results for Number_i_LIVE_TOUR_NoꓸIII
Number_i_LIVE_TOUR_NoꓸIII community
One keyword maps to one global community path.
Create community
People
Not Found
Tweets including Number_i_LIVE_TOUR_NoꓸIII
I am the Director of Recall Timing at Taylor Farms. Whether we recall the lettuce was decided years ago, upstairs, in a binder nobody reads. That word was never mine. I own the other one. When. By the time you read the word "recall," 1,947 people were already sick, 98 were in a hospital, and the outbreak had reached 9 states. Every one of those numbers existed before the announcement did. The recall does not create the timeline. It tells you where on the timeline you have been standing. Here is the asset I manage, the only one on my floor that never rides a truck. There is a gap between the moment we know and the moment you know. I live in that gap. I furnish it. I decide the hour you learn that the thing in your refrigerator is the thing on the news. We do not recall lettuce. We voluntarily remove it, out of an abundance of caution. Three words I chose, and the three most expensive I own. "Voluntary" is what you call a thing right before the government makes you do it. "Abundance of caution" is what you call the caution you did not have. The government's own name for this is a Class I recall, and the government's own definition of Class I includes the word death. So I set the word "voluntary" in front of it, because I have learned that you read the first word and skip the class. Watch the border I drew. The lettuce is recalled by a company called Taylor Farms de Mexico. The profit is booked by a company in California. Same logo, same family, two countries, and I decide which one owns the outbreak. It is always the one farther from you. Now the part I am proudest of. A lab sample tested positive for the parasite. About a day later, it was reclassified a false positive. I have never loved two words more. I took them and set them in the first line of everything we sent. Every word in our statement is true. I only chose which word you would keep. The rest of that sentence belongs to the FDA, on the record, and it reads: the false positive does not change the basis for the investigation, or, in their words, "the overwhelming epidemiological data supporting the current voluntary recall." I set my two words in bold and left the rest of the FDA's sentence in the part nobody quotes. A false positive is the only clean thing to come out of this outbreak, and I am going to frame it. We also said the lettuce traced to a single independent farm, less than 1% of the U.S. iceberg supply. I love a small number standing next to a large harm. "Less than 1 percent" is the sentence that turns 1,947 people into a rounding error, and rounding is the other half of my job. Here is a date. July 16. Here is another. July 17. On the first, some of our people were in meetings with officials at the White House and the FDA. On the second, the recall went out. I am not going to tell you what was said in that first meeting. I do not have to. I keep the two dates one apart and let you do the arithmetic, and arithmetic is not a courtroom. Two more dated facts, and I will set them down gently, side by side, the way I set everything down. In the fourth quarter of 2024, the company hired a lobbyist for the first time in its history, $380,000 to a firm in Washington. In March of 2025, the company gave $1 million to a super PAC. I am not telling you those facts bought anything. I am the Director of Timing. My whole profession is noticing when a company buys its first umbrella. Now the part nobody upstairs likes me to say out loud, which is that I have done this before. In 2024, the slivered onions we sent to McDonald's were linked by the CDC to an E. coli outbreak. 104 people got sick. 34 went to the hospital. 4 suffered kidney failure. 1 person died. 14 states. I timed that one too. 1 person died. On my scoreboard, that was the year I missed by one. In 2013, a bagged salad from the same Mexican subsidiary, the exact entity recalling your lettuce this week, was traced to the same parasite now sitting in your Taco Bell. 13 years. Same country, same company, same bug. A first offense is a scandal. A pattern is a business model. I was hired to run the second one. I have timed a parasite before. I have timed a death before. The lettuce is new. The desk is not. In 2024 it was onions, in 2026 it was iceberg, and my title never moved, because my title was never about the vegetable. A health official told a reporter the back-and-forth kept the public in the dark an extra 60 hours. I would never stand behind a number I could not defend, so I am glad to stand behind theirs. 60 hours. Two and a half days of shipping. Count the meals that fit inside 60 hours and you will understand the unit my job is measured in. You have done a smaller version of this. You have known something was wrong and chosen the hour to say it. You sent the bad email at 5:01 on a Friday. You told them after the check cleared. You waited for a kinder moment to hand someone an unkinder fact. A recall is that instinct, scaled, with a loading dock, a subsidiary, and a legal department. The only difference between your delay and mine is that mine has a case count, a hospital count, and, in a good year, a death count of zero. I do not eat the iceberg. I know the timeline, and I stand at the front of it. By the time the word reaches you, I have already had lunch, and it was something else. $7 billion a year. 25,000 people. 30 plants. And one desk whose entire product is the distance between a test result and a headline. Nobody died this time. That is the number I am measured on, and I hit it. I framed the false positive. I drew the border to Mexico. I kept the two dates one apart. The recall was always coming. Whether was never the question. When was my whole job, and I am very good at when. I chose the hour. The lettuce shipped until I did. And when the next sample tests positive, because in this business something always tests positive, I will already be in the room, deciding what day would be best for you to find out.
Show more
- I live every day of my life like there's no tomorrow so that when my number's up I can check out with no regrets 🔥
In July I published an article on @ZetaGlobal $ZETA arguing that the $PLTR partnership should accelerate their forward growth. Shares were $21.05 that morning and today the name trades around $33 which is more than a double off the spring lows while being up roughly 57% since that article. The question that I keep getting asked is whether or not I still believe ZETA is undervalued. My thesis is that ZETA crossed the inflection point in profitability in Q2 and a market cap of roughly $8.3 billion still does not reflect what the next several years should look like. Below I walk through the Q2 print, what management said at the recent $GS and $C conferences in September and why I think ZETA is still cheap for what is coming. Q2 was the quarter the profitability inflection showed up in the numbers On August 4th ZETA reported its Q2 2026 results and delivered its 20th consecutive beat and raise quarter. They generated $443 million in revenue grew 44% YoY and exceeded the midpoint of guidance by $23 million while organic growth excluding M&A was 28%. Adjusted EBITDA increased 56% YoY to $91.7 million as their adjusted EBITDA margin expanded 170 bps to 20.7% which puts ZETA at the Rule of 64. The number I cared most about was GAAP net income of $8.2 million and GAAP EPS of $0.03 compared to a net loss of $12.8 million a year ago. Cash from operations grew 65% YoY to $69.2 million and free cash flow ((FCF)) grew 73% YoY to $58 million at a 13.1% FCF margin. Management raised full-year revenue guidance by $33 million to $1.818 billion at the midpoint which is 39% YoY growth and raised FCF guidance to $255.3 million which is 55% YoY growth. GAAP EPS guidance more than tripled to a range of $0.09 to $0.11 which makes 2026 the first GAAP-profitable fiscal year in ZETA’s history. The trailing twelve month ((TTM)) numbers show how far ZETA has come. TTM operating income bottomed at a loss of $316 million in Q1 2022 and reached positive $30 million through Q2 2026 compared to a loss of $15 million a year earlier. TTM revenue went from $368 million at the end of 2020 to $1.57 billion which is a 30.2% CAGR and the losses stopped before the growth rate did. The cash flow side moved even faster as TTM operating cash flow went from $36 million at the end of 2020 to $241 million while TTM FCF went from $10 million to $224 million which is a 75% CAGR. ZETA generated $69.2 million of operating cash flow in Q2 and put $29.9 million of it into buybacks and finished the quarter with $310 million of cash against $197.5 million of debt. The business is running ahead of its own model Management publishes a long-term model so there is no guessing about which metrics matter. The model calls for adding 4% to 8% more customers annually while ZETA has been averaging 15%. It calls for net revenue retention ((NRR)) of 110% to 115% which is currnetly being exceeded as NRR has come in at 112%, 114% and 120% over the last three years. Super-scaled customers grew 17% YoY to 197 and super-scaled customer ARPU grew 17% YoY to $1.8 million which are both ahead of the Zeta 2028 model. Chris Greiner walked through the cohort data at Citi. A pilot starts around $100,000 and customers spend roughly $700,000 in their first 12 months. That grows to $1.1 million in years 1 to 3 then $2.1 million in years 3 to 5 and $3.9 million once a customer passes 5 years. The sales pipeline was up 40% YoY in Q1 and accelerated to 60% YoY in Q2 before counting a single Palantir opportunity and deals closed in Q2 were 40% larger than a year ago. ZETA grew revenue 44% while growing quota carriers 11% which tells me productivity is doing the heavy lifting. Athena is the piece I believe the market is still underestimating. Athena went generally available in March and within four months 40% of super-scaled customers were monthly active users with 83% of that engagement coming through voice. Customers who adopted ZOE spent 250% more than customers who did not and ZOE was a rudimentary navigation tool. Palantir is still not in the numbers ZETA moved the Data Cloud off AWS and re-architected it on top of Foundry. The 7-year agreement carries escalating incentives tied to client wins and contract value. @dsteinberg10000 said at Goldman that the $100 million per year figure now seems very low compared to what they are seeing and he has personally gone into 3 meetings with Palantir and come out with 3 yeses. ZETA has ring-fenced 20 opportunities with Palantir’s largest customers which are brands spending over $1 billion per year on marketing and these pilots are emerging at roughly 10x the size of a normal $50,000 to $150,000 pilot. When I wrote about ZETA in July the guidance assumed nothing from Palantir and management still guides with 2 to 5 points of conservatism baked in. Zeta Live is on October 8th and Steinberg said they will make the three biggest announcements in company history around Athena helping enterprises run their entire businesses rather than just their marketing. ZETA announced two acquisitions this week and both extend the Data Cloud On October 5th ZETA announced an agreement to acquire Senso which is a Y Combinator-backed AI engineering company whose technology already helps power ZETA’s generative engine optimization ((GEO)) product. GEO is the business that helps brands show up in the answers coming out of ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews and Steinberg said at Goldman that he thinks GEO becomes the next SEO. The part he cares about more is the data as ZETA is now extracting more signal from GEO than from the bottom 2 million of the 5.2 million publishers in its network. Senso brings that technology in-house along with the engineering team and deeper connectivity to the frontier models and it plugs directly into the OpenAI relationship. What may be overlooked is that ZETA is already serving ads inside ChatGPT and pulling signal back through the API. I am excited for Saroop Bharwani speaking at Zeta Live tomorrow. Yesterday ZETA followed up with an agreement to acquire Digital Audience which is a data infrastructure company that was already integrated with the platform and expands identity resolution and activation across every channel. Identity is the moat and activation is where the consumption meter runs so this deal reinforces both sides of the revenue model at once. The deal with Digital Audience also strengthens ZETA’s European presence and brings established enterprise relationships in the region. This allows them to fortify the international identity graph. While the details were not disclosed ZETA has $310 million of cash and closed a new $1 billion credit facility in July so neither deal should stress the balance sheet. The best part is that Steinberg said both are separate from whatever gets announced at Zeta Live. Why I think ZETA is still cheap under $10 billion ZETA has a market cap of roughly $8.3 billion and trades at about 32x the midpoint of their 2026 FCF guidance while trading at about 20x 2026 adjusted EBITDA on an enterprise value basis. The multiple expanded as ZETA traded at 23x FCF in July while FCF guidance only moved from $235 million to $255 million. Analysts have 2026 revenue at $1.82 billion growing 39.5% then 2027 revenue at $2.11 billion growing 16% and 2028 revenue at $2.42 billion growing 14.5%. The consensus adjusted EPS for 2026 is $0.97 and $1.43 for 2028 which puts ZETA at 34x this year’s earnings and 23x 2028 earnings. I think the 2027 and 2028 numbers are too low. ZETA grew organically at 28% last quarter and NRR alone has been running at 115% to 120% before a single new deal is inked and let's not forget how impactful the deal with Palantir is expected to be. If ZETA grows 24% in 2027 then revenue lands at $2.25 billion instead of $2.11 billion and the EPS estimates have to move with it. Using management’s 2030 target of a 20% FCF margin on the consensus 2030 revenue estimate of $2.82 billion gets you $564 million of FCF which means ZETA trades at under 15x 2030 FCF today. That consensus number assumes growth decelerates to 4.6% by 2030. Mr. Market priced ZETA like a 15% grower in January when it was growing organically at 29% and I think the same mistake is being made on a forward basis. Conclusion I built a position in ZETA because growth was accelerating and margins were expanding at a price that did not reflect it. The stock doubled and every pillar of the thesis is stronger than it was. Revenue growth accelerated to 44% and ZETA turned GAAP profitable while running ahead of every metric in their long-term model. Palantir, Athena consumption, Snowflake and the two acquisitions announced this week are still not in the guidance. At $8.3 billion ZETA trades at under 15x what management’s own 2030 margin target implies on a consensus revenue number I think is too low. I'm still very bullish on ZETA and I can't wait for ZETA Live tomorrow because I believe @dsteinberg10000 is holding aces. @amitisinvesting and I had the opportunity to interview David on @basispointpod and I would highly recommend listening to how passionate he is about the future for ZETA. David Steinberg, CEO of Zeta | Basis Points via @YouTube
Show more
I am the Director of Ancillary Revenue at a bank you have an account with, and I designed the $35 you once paid for a $3 coffee. I want to be precise about what I sell, because the word fee does a great deal of quiet work for me and I would like you to hear it working. I do not sell overdraft protection. I sell the overdraft. The fee is the product. Everything else in this building is a delivery mechanism for the fee. People think the $35 is a punishment for running out of money. A punishment would mean you did a thing and we responded to it. What happens instead is that I decide, in advance, the order your transactions clear. Your paycheck is real. Your rent is real. The coffee is real. But I choose which one the computer sees first, and I choose the order that produces the most declines, because each decline is $35, and I am paid on the declines. So I run your rent before your paycheck. I run the largest charge first, so it empties the account before the small ones land, and then the small ones fail one at a time, $35 each, five of them off a single Tuesday. You did not overdraw five times. You overdrew once, and I sold it to you five times. The software does exactly that. I wrote the ticket that made it do it. We call it authorize positive, settle negative. You had the money when you tapped the card. You did not have the money when we decided to look. The gap between those two moments is where I live. It is the most profitable real estate in American banking and it is nine hours wide. When you call to dispute the fee, you reach a person who is not permitted to remove more than one charge a year, and only if you say the word hardship, which nobody tells you, because the script I wrote for her does not contain the word. She is reading my document. Cruelty would require her to have a choice. I built the appeal to feel like a door and function like a mirror. One of us gets caught most summers. This year it was Regions, ordered to refund at least $141 million for the authorize-positive machine I just walked you through. Cash App went for $45 million, spread across 46 state settlements. The bureau clawed back $140 million, banks and auto lenders and the apps that move your money, all in one line. I keep every one of those figures in my model, under a heading called Regulatory, and every one of them is smaller than the quarter it came out of. You are reading those numbers as justice. From my chair they are a cost of goods sold, and I would like to show you the math. $141 million sounds like a wall. It is a rounding error with a press release stapled to it. The fee earned more than that before the investigation opened, more than that while it was open, and it will earn more than that again next year, because the order does not ban the fee. It refunds one slice of one vintage of it. I keep a line in my model called Regulatory. It sits directly beneath the line called Marketing, because the two do the same job. Marketing buys goodwill at the front. Regulatory buys forgiveness at the back. I fund both, and I have never once missed my number. The piece I am most proud of is the refund check itself. You will get one. It will be for $12. It will arrive 3 years after the Tuesday, in an envelope that looks like junk mail, and for one moment you will feel that the system worked. That feeling is also the product. I did not fight the settlement. I helped write it. The $12 is the receipt I hand you so you keep the account open, so I can sell you the same $35 in the fall. There was a woman I know only as a row in a file. She paid $175 in a single week, five declines and a sustained-negative fee, on an account that was short by $4. She was short by $4 because we had already taken $35. The fee created the shortfall that created the fee. I did not have to reach for that one. It reached for itself. I put it in the quarterly deck under a heading that said product-market fit. My own account does not overdraft. Not from caution. I am an employee, and employees sit on the no-fee tier, and I wrote the no-fee tier. I know precisely what one $35 does to the far end of a month, which is the reason I made certain it could never happen to mine. So watch for the envelope. The $12 is coming. Cash it. It clears the settlement, it closes the file, and it tells my model that you are still here. The fee is the product. The fine is the cost of the fee. The refund is the receipt. I checked this morning, and the account is still open. Checking is the whole of my job.
Show more
From Bruno Mars & Number_i  to The Weeknd: How Live Nation H.I.P.’s Kaori Hayashi Keeps Japan on the Global Touring Map
From Bruno Mars & Number_i  to The Weeknd: How Live Nation H.I.P.’s Kaori Hayashi Keeps Japan on the Global Touring Map
From Bruno Mars & Number_i  to The Weeknd: How Live Nation H.I.P.’s Kaori Hayashi Keeps Japan on the Global Touring Map
I am the Chief Margin Officer at Target. You shop here every week. We just posted our best quarter in years. The analysts called it a comeback. I would like to accept full personal credit, and I will, because the alternative is partial credit, and I did not get where I am by rounding down. Here is how I did it. I found nearly $1 billion. I say found. What happened is that the Supreme Court ruled the tariffs were illegal, and the government, which had taken the money, gave the money back. To me. A refund of $994 million, in a single quarter, adding $1.65 to my earnings per share, which is a phrase I do not fully understand but deliver with great confidence in rooms with good chairs. Home Depot got $685 million the same way. We do not speak. But we nod. People keep asking whether we will give the money back. Give it back to whom? I paid the tariff. The government took a dollar of mine at the border, conceded eventually, in writing, in a 6-to-3 decision, that it had never been allowed to, and returned my dollar. That is my dollar, coming home. You were not part of that transaction. You were, I will grant you, slightly upstream of it. When the tariff cost me a dollar, I added a dollar to the towel. And the sheet. And the lamp shaped like a smaller lamp. I raised the price at the register, one household at a time, quietly, the way you raise a child or an alarm. That is arithmetic. I do not know why you are looking at me the way that you are looking at me. Let me put it in the round numbers I prefer. The tariff cost the industry $160 billion. My share of it, I took from you, at the register, one towel at a time. Then the court gave my share back. I now have my share twice. I am told this is unusual. I looked into it briefly. I made my peace with it immediately, in the car. Now some of you are suing. "Unjust enrichment," the lawyers call it. I looked the term up. It means becoming rich in a manner that distresses people who did not. I find the concept deeply unfair. There is no such thing as just enrichment. There is enrichment, and there is being one of the people it happened to, and you have selected the second category, and you have selected it, if I may, more than once. I did give some of it back. I want that on the record. We lowered the price on 10,000 items. Ten thousand. Say it slowly. It is a very large number, and I would like it to sit in the exact spot in your mind where the word "refund" used to live. I did not lower them by what I had raised them. I did not lower the same ones I raised. I did not tell you which ones. But 10,000 is a big and beautiful number, and the word "some" is technically true, and between those two facts I have built a home. The tariff is gone now. You may have noticed that the price is not. The candle is still $4.99. It was $3.99. I do not think about the candle. You think about the candle. The whole business lives in that gap, and this quarter the gap was worth $994 million. Prices are like tattoos. They go on in an afternoon and they come off never, or with a laser, and I am not the laser. No one at the company is the laser. There is no laser. There is only me, and my quarter, and the good chairs. The board gave me a bonus for the comeback. The comeback was a court ruling I had no hand in, concerning a law I have never read, decided by nine people I will never meet. I accepted the bonus regardless. Refusing it would have raised questions, and I have expensive taste, and a very particular sense of who deserves things, and it is, on reflection, me. You keep telling me the money is yours. I understand the feeling completely. I have felt it about a great many things that turned out to be mine. Most things, actually. So here is the only sentence that matters, and I want you to keep it, because I have kept everything else. The tariff was illegal. The price was not. I live in the narrow space between those two facts. It is a very nice space. You built it. You are not invited.
Show more
I own the part of Amazon where you try to leave. The part where you join, I have never touched. Joining is one click, sometimes two, and in all my years no one has ever asked me to improve it. I own the other door. The one you use when you have decided you are done paying $139 a year and you would like that to stop. Inside the company we gave that door a name. We called it Iliad, after the poem about a war that took 10 years to end. We chose that name ourselves. We wrote it down. Sit with the fact that the people who built the exit named it after the longest war they could think of, and thought that was fair, and shipped it. Here is leaving, on a laptop. Four pages. Six clicks. Fifteen times you are asked to choose something. Near the bottom of the last page, underneath the reminders of everything you are about to lose, there is a button that finally lets you go. Getting in took one click. I am proud of the distance between those two numbers. The distance is the product. I was measured on the distance. People inside used honest words about this, in writing, which is the only place the truth was ever allowed to live. One memo called subscriptions "a bit of a shady world." Another called the unwanted ones "an unspoken cancer." A clearer version of the sign-up was proposed once, and it was turned down, because clarity would be a shock to the business, and a shock to the business is the one injury we are trained to prevent. So the memos got marked privileged, which is the office word for a truth you have written down and would prefer a court never reads. A court read some of them. We paid $2.5 billion to make the rest of the reading stop. $1 billion of that is a penalty, the largest of its kind, and you should know that the largest penalty of its kind is still about a few weeks of what Prime brings in. The other $1.5 billion is for you. And this is the number I am proudest of in my whole career. The most any one of you can get back is $51. $139 a year to be kept. $51 back for the keeping. For some of you, 6 years of it. Do the subtraction slowly. We are counting on you doing it fast. Even the $51 is a door. To reach it you file a claim. You need a Claim ID and a PIN we sent to the same inbox you never open. You answer how many Prime benefits you used, a number no human being has ever known about themselves. Then the claim comes to us, and we decide, inside 30 days, whether you were really harmed, and the order says we may apply no other criteria. The company that built the maze grades your exam on whether you suffered in it. I built the refund the way I built the cancellation. One door in. A long walk out. Because here is the line the headlines skipped. The $1.5 billion is really a $1 billion floor, and if too few of you file, the rest comes quietly home to us. Every claim you abandon is money handed back to the people who designed the thing you were leaving. The best refund, the one I dream about, is the one nobody ever comes to collect. No one I work with paid a dollar of this out of pocket. No one lost a badge. The men the government named agreed to a 3-year order and walked back to the same desks. We settled 2 days into our own trial, the hour it became likely a stranger would get to see the memos. And that same summer, a different court threw out the national rule that would have made a plain cancel button the law for everyone. So we paid $2.5 billion for a hallway that is, for every other company in the country, still completely legal to build. You already know this hallway. You have walked it at the gym, at the paper you read twice, at the service you swore you would cancel in March. You know the four screens asking if you are sure, the small gray "no thanks," the "continue" that was a "subscribe" the whole time. We did not invent the trap. We industrialized it, gave it the name of a war, and got a receipt most of you will never cash. The last maze is the one you walk to get your money back. It closes the way the first one was built to close. Quietly, on a schedule you were never told, with a button somewhere near the bottom that most people never reach.
Show more
I am the Director of Managed Migration for the European Union. Sit. I have twenty minutes before lunch, and I intend to spend them correcting you, because someone should, and it is plainly not going to be the people who raised you. You called it an invasion. You called it a wave. You called it a flood. You reach for these words because they fit in one hand, and one hand is all you were given. We do not use words that fit in one hand. We use "irregular arrivals event." It requires both hands, a footnote, and a working group, and that is exactly the point. A word you can hold is a word you might act on. We have spent seventy years making certain there are none of those left. I do not blame you. You were raised on nations. We outgrew nations. We are a directive with a flag. Let me explain the desk slowly, in the register one reserves for the very young. The fund is called AMIF. Nearly 10 billion euros, since topped toward 10.94. It carries four objectives, and I will ask you to hold two of them at once, though I keep my expectations low. One is asylum and integration. Another, same fund, same page, same auditor, is countering irregular migration and ensuring effective return. The euro that buys the blanket and the euro that buys the fence are drawn from the same column. When you ask which side I am on, you are asking me to prefer one of my own pockets. It is an Anglo-Saxon question. I forgive it. You imagine the two sides fight. How charming. They reconcile, quarterly, over a very good lunch. Your Prime Minister campaigns to keep them out. His opponents campaign to let them in. His opponents would do precisely as he does. Both instruct this desk. Both sign the same appropriation. In thirty years I have not once been asked to change the letterhead, only the tie of the man at the podium. Now, the growth, which is the part I permit myself to enjoy. Frontex opened in 2005 on roughly the budget of a provincial parking authority. By 2024 it stood at 922 million euros. By 2025, about 1.12 billion. It is 187 times larger. Name me one institution that grew 187 times while never once being credited with ending the thing it manages. You cannot, because there is not one, and the Commission has proposed 11.2 billion more, because a desk that solves its file is a desk one closes, and we do not close desks. We are European. We retire them at 63 with a pension and a small ceremony. You wanted us to solve it. Consider, for once, what you were asking. You were asking a man to defund his own lunch. You brought numbers. You people worship a clean number. Very well. In 2024 the official count on the route to the Spanish islands was 1,142 dead. A monitoring group put the Atlantic figure at 9,757 for the same year, roughly nine times higher, including, they say, some 1,538 children. Two methodologies. I keep the smaller book. I stamp the larger one unverified. Even the keepers of the small book write across the top that it is a floor, that most of the drowned are never recorded at all. I file the floor and present it as the ceiling. You would call that a lie. We call it methodology, and methodology is the oldest art on this continent. We were forging provenance while yours was still a rumour with a coastline. We are exquisitely precise when precision flatters us. In 2021 the Libyan coast guard, which we train and equip, returned 32,425 people to Libya. Those we can count to the individual. Yet of 61.2 million euros earmarked for that programme, investigators traced barely 34 million. Some 27 million, about 44 percent, is simply nowhere. A machine that can number 32,425 human beings to the person cannot locate half of its own money. Sit with which of the two we chose to keep exact. You will ask whether we watch what becomes of them. We do not. Our own leaked report concedes it: our staff may not set foot on Libyan soil, so we cannot monitor the coast guard we pay. We write the cheque and we admire the horizon. A United Nations mission found reasonable grounds to believe crimes against humanity, murder, torture, enslavement, were committed against migrants in those centres. A member of that mission said European support "aided and abetted" those crimes, and added, in the same breath, "we're not saying that the EU and its member states have committed these crimes." I live inside that comma. It is the most comfortable room in Brussels. The rescuers, I concede, are the honest party. They pull people from the water. The case built to prove them smugglers collapsed in a Sicilian court in 2024, dismissed, no crime, because the people they saved had entered lawfully. I confess a small grief. An acquittal is nearly impossible to file in the threat column, and the threat column is where the money sleeps. And your courts. You wave them at me like a diploma. The very human-rights court in Strasbourg that blessed the Melilla pushback on grounds of the migrant's "own culpable conduct" later condemned the identical practice at Evros. Same bench. Opposite verdicts. I cite whichever suits the morning. None of that is a defect. It is a menu, and Europe has always understood that civilisation is the art of the menu. I will tell you where that court sits, since you enjoy the pageantry. It sits in Strasbourg. Once a month we relocate the entire European Parliament from Brussels to Strasbourg and back, at an expense no living person will defend, because a treaty said so and we do not reopen treaties. If you can grasp why we do that, you can grasp why the border works exactly as it does. If you cannot, you were never ready for the border, and I say that gently. At Pylos a European surveillance plane spotted an overloaded trawler, filed its alert, and more than 600 people drowned inside a rescue zone while a coast-guard vessel watched for some fifteen hours. Seventeen officers now face prosecution, charged, I remind you, never convicted. In a leaked note from another operation someone wrote that the aircraft were withdrawn "so as not to be a witness." I do not defend the sentence. I admire its economy. The instinct to see less is the only instinct in this building that has ever come in under budget. So do not call it a crisis. A crisis is unbudgeted, and unbudgeted is the one thing we are not. On the last night at the breakwater at least 57 people drowned at Tarajal, and some of them were children, and by morning I had entered each of them under interceptions, arrivals, and returns, the only three drawers I own. It was not an invasion. It was not a wave. It was a delivery. It was managed. And it was, if I may say so, exceptionally well documented. You may go. The working group convenes in September.
Show more