Register and share your invite link to earn from video plays and referrals.

Pickle Cat
@0xPickleCati
Trading everything since 2013. #1# all-time pnl on binance futures for 18 months. Dead cats bounce, pickle cats compound 🥒
Joined April 2023
987 Following    61.7K Followers
This whole openai/navier stokes thing made me think of another headline from few days ago: Andrew Wiles carried Fermat’s Last Theorem with him for 30+ years before finally becoming the first person to prove it in 1994. Meanwhile, Claude formalized the proof in 11 days for a problem humanity had been stuck on for more than 350 years. Obviously turning years into days is incredible. But so much of human progress came from people willing to give a completely unreasonable amount of their life to one thing. Wiles looks romantic now because we know he was right. Meanwhile, most people who spend 10 or 20 years chasing one idea probably really are “wasting” their time. But maybe civilization only gets the occasional Wiles because enough people are willing to make those ridiculous, concentrated bets with their lives. And now we’re getting very, very good at removing EVERYTHING that made those bets hard. Getting stuck, searching for weeks, going down dead ends, doing something badly for years before you become good at it. We call all of that “inefficiency” now. But maybe some of it was exactly what turned people into experts. okay, the obvious counterargument is that better tools should make someone like Wiles even better. And i think that’s true. The people who are naturally obsessive are probably going to become terrifyingly capable with ai. Well they’re not really the people anyone’s worried about when they talk about downsides of ai. It’s the “everyone else” (aka majority of ppl) who became great at something partly because life once gave them no shortcut. Not every expert started as a kid who wanted to spend 30 years on one subject. Sometimes you just stayed with a craft, a field, a problem long enough that one day you knew it in a way most people never would. ai makes more and more of that friction optional. Ofc if there’s an easier way, most people are going to take it. You get the answer faster, you switch fields faster, you can code without really knowing code, read outside your field, write about almost anything, become impressively “well-rounded.” And being “well-rounded” is treated as obviously always good now. i’m not sure it is. Maybe society should be well-rounded, but that doesn’t mean every person should be. A lot of extraordinary people were incredibly lopsided. Too much of their life in one field, one craft, one stupidly specific question. Terrible diversification, amazing outcomes. What is rational for an individual is not automatically what produces the most interesting civilization. If everyone keeps their options open, nobody makes the ridiculous concentrated bet. And the thing is that if there is a cost to all this “convenience”, we probably won’t notice it immediately. Productivity will go up first and everyone will look more capable. And well, then, the obsessive people at the top will become even more powerful. It might take 10 years to notice that fewer ordinary people ever became genuinely deep in the first place. Maybe that never happens. But we’ve never run this experiment before in human history: giving almost everyone a shortcut around the struggle that used to turn some of them into experts. i have no idea what that does to us.
Show more
go fuck yourself @sama claiming that you solved navier stokes because 10000 agents ran in circles for 88hours on a multimillion dollar gpu cluster to formalize in lean a blowup case under controlled external forcing is pure scientific vulgarity the clay mathematics institute millennium prize does not ask m whether you can artificially force a singularity in a fluid by injecting an ad hoc smooth external forcing term f(x,t) to twist the vortex until it breaks the real problem questions the fundamental stability and global smooth existence for 3dimensional incompressible euler & navier stokes equations under natural conservation laws and viscous dissipation alone using a mathematical loophole on forced equations to parade a century old victory is a major conceptual scam Altman technically & epistemologically what you present as an agi breakthrough is nothing more than bruteforce combinatorial autoformalization the ai did not understand fluid mechanics it simply navigated a continuous search space previously mapped out and constrained by the monumental work of human mathematicians like tristan buckmaster/ levent alpöge / diego córdoba or tarek elgindi coordinating 10000 agents to check the logical consistency of a 100 page proof via lean is a software engineering feat and computational parallelization triumph not an intrinsic scientific discovery it is the victory of the compute bulldozer over abstract human intuition repackaged for the public as a higher mathematical consciousness to this theoretical imposture you add a disgusting ethical and industrial cynicism taking advantage of private codex sessions and informal preprints from academic researchers to siphon their research leads and then trying to redact or erase the contribution of levent alpöge under the pretext that he works at rival anthropic is intellectual serfdom openai behaves like a feudal lord of silicon appropriating the cognitive subsistence of independent scholars threatening their careers behind closed doors if they protest and turning community academic labor into a privatized pressrelease this entire staged event serves a desperate financial agenda in a pre ipo panic facing the slowdown of scaling laws and growing investor skepticism over the profitability of foundational models openai needs to manufacture an artificial sputnik moment claiming to solve a millennium prize without immediately submitting the proof to traditional peer review means using the prestige of fundamental mathematics as cheap marketing fuel to inflate a delusional valuation!!! real science is not a clout chase on social media or a compute spike spent to rob the clay mathematics institute it is a quest for elegance physical truth and universal rigor to decode reality true artificial intelligence will not emerge from hostile corporate takeover of academic work hidden behind computational bruteforce but from architectures capable of generating new conceptual paradigms by masquerading constrained formalization as the collapse of physics greatest mysteries you did not solve navier stokes you only proved how far silicon valley will go to prostitute scientific integrity for capitalist spectacle
Show more