Sweden has tougher environmental rules than America. It also gets more of its energy from renewables than any other EU country. A permitting bill in Congress, BAAJA, would make our system work more like Sweden’s.
In Sweden, a lawsuit against a project (like a wind farm) is about its actual harm.
In the US, you can sue over whether the government’s thousand-page environmental review left something out. If a judge agrees, the permit is canceled and the agency starts over, even if the project wouldn’t have hurt anything in real life!
Federal agencies win about 80% of these cases on appeal. The cases still take over four years. A lot of projects can’t survive that wait.
Imagine clean energy groups, environmental groups, and the government all agree on a new wind farm. Today, a rival company or a single neighbor can stall it for years.
Under BAAJA, you’d have 150 days to sue, and you’d need to show the project actually harms you. If a judge finds a gap in the review, the agency fixes only that part, within 180 days. The project doesn’t go back to square one. Cases go straight to federal appeals courts, so plaintiffs can’t pick a friendly judge.
That’s still short of Sweden, where environmental courts with technical experts judge projects based on their impact. But it’s a big step.
The bill also moves us toward Sweden’s model of empowered civil servants. It makes it harder for political appointees to cancel already-approved projects. Trump’s Interior Department halted five already-approved offshore wind farms. BAAJA would make that harder, though that same power could apply to a future Democratic administration wanting to stop an oil permit.
Renewables keep getting cheaper. When it’s easier to build energy of any kind, I expect most of what gets built to be renewables, even though the bill helps oil and gas too. It just helps all energy projects.
Many House Democrats are waiting to see what environmental groups say. I hope the Sierra Club and NRDC sign on.