I do not understand this debate.
But since everyone involved seems to love thought experiments, letâs try this one on.
Imagine you could connect a fresh âhumanâ form factor brain to a computer.
It has never been attached to a human body.
- No prior experience.
- No childhood.
- No memories.
- It has no sense of smell, taste or touch.
- Its sense of sight & hearing are limited & high friction
- It cannot feel physical pain.
- Without the ability to experience physical sensation, its ability to experience any type of emotional feelings are at the very least dramatically altered, if possible at all
- It cannot die.
- It is simply receiving input & responding or it is inactive
It is then given the ability to read text on the internet, and by happenstance it finally manages to organize itself to understand what it has read and respond to questions.
Does that biological neural net, that happens to share a form factor with a humanâs brain, have a consciousness that is in any way relatable to you and I?
Obviously not.
Thatâs why the idea that modern LLMâs should be treated with the same standing that we otherwise reserve for other humans is absolutely ridiculous.
Itâs the same basic fallacy as the claim that discarding an embryo during IVF is tantamount to murder.
No. It obviously is not the same thing.