2 super high-growth subscription brands pulled me in on their retention.
They were buying customers into a 6-month payback. The product pays back in under 2.
Both said the same thing: "Come diagnose our retention, something's breaking."
I told them their retention problem was actually an acquisition problem WEARING a retention costume.
The plumbing you can fix all day:
> the reminders
> the cadence
> the portal updates
> the communication flow
Every brand has that work once someone actually looks. The win was telling them the truth about their offer.
What was actually broken:
> their core product, even at a healthy AOV, was never going to build into a real LTV play
> a 6-month payback on a product that pays back in under 2 (1.6, to be exact)
But they hated hearing it because the “growth” looked too good to question.
So I said it straight..for right now, it works. The second your churn outpaces the growth of your subscription base, you go right back to losing.
Takeaway: "Our LTV is broken" was never the real problem.