On-chain matters because it enables:
- Verifiability: you actually know the rules of the venue you’re trading on vs ”trust mes”; can build venues without unilateral oracle price changes or first look by an internal maker. You also can get some execution guarantees.
- Atomic transaction composability: ex. can open a position on separate venues in one all-or-nothing transaction, can move funds between protocols without brittle bridging.
- Lower risk of censorship/exploitation: you can build, choose, find protocols that have frozen admins or more distributed admins; would need tens of billions of capital to properly capture chain stake and censor; greatly lower venue risk.
- Long term alignment: stable API with real money behind it, many stable users even as top app changes, many protocols can survive their labs counterpart shutting down so you can think long term.
- Unified liquidity: spot flows easily even though margin requires deeper cross program APIs;
- Answer to some regulatory risk: jurisdictions have a right to regulate their territories but are forced to apply different rules to credibly decentralized systems that span legal systems.
This vision hasn’t been fully delivered yet; but on-chain is what unlocks it; quite frankly: the state transitions need to be on distributed consensus; otherwise the admin of state will one day exploit or fall short.