Register and share your invite link to earn from video plays and referrals.

Dr. Brian L. Cox
@BrianCox_RLTW
Senior Fellow @MLInstitute. JSD & fmr prof @CornellLaw. MA @JSchool_CU. Ret. @USArmy (11B, 25R, 25V, 11A, 27A). Tar Heel x2. Views my own. Rangers Lead the Way.
Joined August 2024
251 Following    39.2K Followers
The more this drama queen goes on about this "harrowing" encounter, the more he demonstrates to the world just how utterly unfit he is to hold public office. So, let's clear a few things up from just this post alone. First, there is nothing about this incident that qualifies as "detention/false imprisonment." Not that these terms are completely synonymous, but neither one happened here. See, even the one with the lower definitional threshold - false imprisonment - requires some degree of restraint. Specifically, a person must be "intentionally restrained" in a manner "that confines the individual within a bounded area" (pic 1). Blocking a person's path may qualify as false imprisonment, but the act of doing so must confine a person within a bounded area to do so. Even footage made public by the "victims" on the ground shows they were free to proceed in the opposite direction - which by definition does not meet the definition for false imprisonment (let alone "detention"). Second, a false imprisonment (or, "unlawful detention") must be conducted with no legal authority in order to be a violation (also pic 1). Since Kry Baby Khanna is making broad comparisons with "America and most democracies" here related to his treatment by @Israel, let's continue - for now - to analyze how ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ law would apply to a similar situation at home. You may recall that Rep. Ro & his band of merry misfits were initially, er ... "detained", by private individuals then @IDF security personnel. The first component engages with what is referred to colloquially as "citizen's arrest," and the second could arguably (but not actually) involve a civil action for violation of rights. Regarding citizen's arrest, EVERY SINGLE STATE in the Union allows some form of private detention - whether rooted in common law or statute. Georgia statutory law is among the most restrictive since it was amended in 2021 following the death of Ahmaud Arbery. Although this statute severely restricted the practice of "citizen's arrest," it is still permissible under limited circumstances (such as detaining a person for police custody in response to a situation in which the victim may use defensive force). Although all states are able to legislate or otherwise modify law involving private detention, the point is that EVERY SINGLE ONE allows it in one form or another. And that is exactly what happened to Ro et al here - at least initially, and at least the "private" (but not "detention") component. The offenders (that's Ro & his team) were entering a restricted area without prior permission or coordination & they were interdicted (NOT detained) by private individuals until security officials arrived. Comparing this incident to relevant ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ law would require a state-by-state analysis to determine whether the private persons acted with legal authority under the circumstances ... and remember, under NO circumstances would this constitute false "imprisonment" to begin with. Finally, let's shift from the initial private interdiction to the official acts involved - again pursuant to ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ law. The most relevant federal statute that comes to mind is 42 USC ยง 1983, civil action for deprivation of rights (pic 2). Here, the purported "right" might be the constitutional right to peaceable assembly, under a theory that the group had a right to assemble & hear from Arab residents of Judea and Samaria. The trouble with advancing this potential ground for civil liability is that the official must deprive the victim of a right secured by the Constitution and laws. And while the ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ Constitution does permit peaceable assembly, this right - like any other - is not absolute. That is, there are laws that prohibit persons from entering, for example, controlled access portions of military installations. Or ... emergency cordons created in response to natural disasters. And so on. So Ro et al could advance a claim, pursuant to ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ law, regarding some form of civil action for deprivation of rights if this incident happened in America (more about that in just a sec). But, again, doing so would be a fact-dependent endeavor - and based on the known facts it is incredibly unlikely that a case brought pursuant to 42 USC ยง 1983 would even advance to the merits in district court. Now, I don't claim to be a specialist in the laws of "most democracies" - but certainly for most common law countries a similar analysis would bring similar results. Even so, this entire exercise misses just one tiny but important detail: THIS ENTIRE FUCKING EPISODE OCCURRED EITHER IN ISRAEL OR DISPUTED TERRITORY OF JUDEA AND SAMARIA AND IS THEREFORE GOVERNED BY THE LAW THAT APPLIES THERE. This isn't some conceptual, junior associate research exercise in comparative false imprisonment law. It's an actual encounter, that took place in a specific location, and the law related to private "detention" and access to restricted areas & such that applies IN THAT PLACE is all that matters. Period. The absolute arrogance & ignorance these heroes exhibited on the ground at the time by demanding unrestricted access just because a fucking US member of Congress was present is seriously astonishing. As is Ro's subsequent complaining about his treatment THERE as a holder of an American passport. As is his absurd whining here about how he would - or should - be treated for pulling the same shenanigans "in America and most democracies." It's a complete farse, because none of this matters. What actually matters is the law that applies in the place the incident occurred. And not once - as least as far as I can tell - has this hero publicly acknowledged & accounted for the law that applied to him at the time & in that location. Nor does it seem he had any interest in coordinating to assemble with actual victims of false imprisonment: those who were abducted from ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ฑ on 10/7 & subsequently held hostage by literal terrorists in a war zone during an armed conflict the terrorists provoked by unlawfully invading ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ฑ. Likewise, there is no indication that Khanna was interested in coordinating to meet with IDF personnel who worked tirelessly to repatriate all hostages held by #Hamas# terrorists in #Gaza# - often voluntarily risking their own safety to do so. Nor did he try to meet with political leaders like @netanyahu whose steadfast resolve was instrumental in repatriating those who were actually unlawfully detained by Hamas terrorists. If Rep. Ro Khanna were genuinely concerned with actual victims of false imprisonment, he could have pursued any of these activities during his trip to ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ฑ. But, we all know that wasn't the purpose of his visit. And none of those activities would have supported the false narratives he went there to fabricate. See, if your whole schtick is "Israel = bad, so let's all marginalize Israel", but you have to lie to support the "Israel = bad" aspect of the schtick, you are actually the bad actor in the equation. And what should concern us all right now is this entire publicity stunt was coordinated merely to give Ro some anti-Israel cred among @TheDemocrats in preparation for a 2028 presidential bid. That means @BDSmovement priorities are becoming fully mainstream for the left rather than on the far fringes of the progressive movement where they were - and where they still belong - at the time of the Oct 7 atrocities. As for this particular would-be presidential ๐Ÿคก, one would think that a graduate from Yale Law & a former practicing attorney would recall - or at least know how to look up - the elements of "false imprisonment." The fact that he lied about this incident constituting "detention/false imprisonment" - or that he was too incompetent to confirm the elements before spewing this nonsense out loud - demonstrates he is not fit for public office. That includes as a member of the ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ House of Representatives today - and it damn sure applies to his future aspirations to be elected @POTUS in 2028 as well. #TheMoreYouKnow# #legaldisinformation#
Show more
0
18
510
132
Forward to community