Have spent few days looking for on-chain stock that offers the BEST & consistent pricing across sizes.
But disappointed that only 1 provider ticked all the boxes for me...
Mainly two observations:
1. There is a large amount of arb flow that make the historical executed stock price on-chain looks better than it actually is (this applies uniformly to stocks that heavily rely on AMM, such as
@bstocksfinance,
@RobinhoodCrypto,
@base stock). Most retail traders will likely suffer 15-25bps in spread from market price on average, while arber compete to capture negative spread. PropAMM helps here but limited coverage with size still.
2. All AMM based stocks does not have the atomic mint and redeem feature enabled (unlike
@Ondo/
@xStocksFi ). This significantly constrains the access to the primary liquidity sources (i.e. Alpaca's brokerage giving access to underlying market). This forces all the swaps to rely on AMM liquidity.
Conclusion: AMM still suck for stock trading.
Stock providers with atomic mint/redeem suck less. But the latter is still more expensive than to trade directly via local brokers in most cases. Still better than AMM on average.
Given enough time, perhaps propAMM will improve the price execution for retail flow. But unfortunately, we are still far from "cheap" stock trading on-chain for most stock providers.