Some initial thoughts on Grok Bot:
> Very nice overall. I like how much complexity they've removed (very little setup, no model selector, no visible thinking process, etc).
> And yet, it *still* feels way too complex for a mass consumer application. Even as someone who's pretty AI-versed, it took me quite a while to figure out what to actually use the app for. Definitely lacks onboarding and/or pre-built workflows.
> The AI has a surprising amount of agency. When I give it something, it really wants to go and *do* something. Reminds me of the old talkers vs. doers cliche: ChatGPT is great at doing research and coming up with fancy answers, while Grok Bot actually does something with the info you give it.
> It feels very Roam Resarch-coded: I'm having a lot of fun setting up workflows and thinking about everything I could automate, but it's unclear if there are any real productivity gains here or if I'm just playing Lego.
(Related
@WillManidis quote: "The market for feeling productive is orders of magnitude larger than the market for being productive")
> Bots with different skill sets as the form factor is an interesting take, but I'm not 100% convinced it's the ideal structure? I'm a still little confused by the distinction between bots and channels/projects. Would be curious what other form factors the team explored and why they landed here.
> A surprising amount of my usage is triaging information across different applications: put this in Linear, add this to my calendar, put this on our shared to-do list, save this to Obsidian, etc.
> Related: This is the first time Obsidian has really clicked for me. I don't really want to use Obsidian, but using it as a backend that my bots can read and write to is nice.
> I'm missing a single entry point: I want to throw something at the app and have it figure out where it should go. Having to choose the right bot/channel first adds unnecessary friction. A lot of people seem to solve this with a "chief of staff" bot that routes things to other bots. Feels like this should just be purpose-built?
> I want faster input options. Give me iOS home screen widgets for each bot and always accessible hotkeys so I can quickly prompt w/o app/context switching.
> Voice dictation works okay-ish (probably fine 90% of the time) but it struggles with unusual concepts/names and falls apart in noisy environments, which is a huge downside for me. (ChatGPT is exceptionally good at this and it's the main reason I've never switched to another model).