Register and share your invite link to earn from video plays and referrals.

Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Let’s skip witty banter & talk deep Qs. Books: Advisor @_futarchy @MetaDAOProject @butterygg
Joined July 2007
788 Following    127.6K Followers
"rejected … because 'there is no new mathematics'. … distort the direction of the field to look more mathematical. … I wonder if this attitude will change now that doing hard math has become commoditized." Good question.
Show more
Over the past 10 years, I have submitted very few papers to journals. Every once in a while I submit just to test if the peer review system is still as broken as I remember. From earlier this week. I submitted an article on an application of probability in betting. I know for a fact this is actually a useful application that is used in the real world. Which is also why I knew it would be rejected almost immediately -- because why would a real world application be of interest to an academic journal on applied probability? As expected, it was rejected from the Annals of Applied Probability because "there is no new mathematics". A lot of fields, and especially probability, have long had "math envy", so they distort the direction of the field to look more mathematical. (See analytic philosophy for the best example.) I wonder if this attitude will change now that doing hard math has become commoditized.
Show more