Register and share your invite link to earn from video plays and referrals.

Search results for DONT_FIGHT_THE_FEELING
DONT_FIGHT_THE_FEELING community
One keyword maps to one global community path.
Create community
People
Not Found
Tweets including DONT_FIGHT_THE_FEELING
On the occasion of his return Boss @layzhang came to dance! He continues the WE ARE ONE story in the midsummer season! #DONT_FIGHT_THE_FEELING#
0
1.6K
52.7K
27.9K
Forward to community
The game starts now! The moment is ignited with blood, the spacecraft lands, and freedom is released with vitality. Have fun with the 10th boy and enjoy the ride! @layzhang #DONT_FIGHT_THE_FEELING#
Show more
0
2.8K
91.1K
45.8K
Forward to community
the reason the administration is not doing anything about bond yields, in my opinion, is because the stock market is up. when did trump pivot policy in the past? - 2025, SPY down 30% (lol), trump pivots on reciprocal tariffs - 2026, SPY down 9.7%, trump gets a ceasefire with Iran the market is barely off from ATHs. if people were feeling it in their 401ks, like really feeling the pain, the admin would be doing something about it. that's what they use to judge themselves. bond yields keep going up and the market continuing to give trump the benefit of the doubt means he and besssent probably think they have more time and don't have to take action as quickly. if stocks were to really, really dump...then historical evidence shows us that Trump would pivot. if they don't, then the resiliency of the market will continue to fight the Fed and give Trump time to eventually end the war.
Show more
There's a crazy reason behind how I understood the true importance of fully decentralizing compute. The story needs telling, so here goes. Back in 2015, I'd long shifted to being part of the early crypto scene, but maintained Fight My Monster, a venture-backed MMO game & social network I previously founded that had 3M users, which was self-sustaining financially. I'd found a long-term home working on decentralized compute, but couldn't let down the community that played the game. Fight My Monster was built in 2010-2012, using what was a completely novel architecture at the time that enabled it to scale (i.e. add massive amounts of users) at low cost, and with minimal administration. Essentially it comprised three core backend components. The first, was simple web hosting, which served the frontend game code and assets into its users' web browsers (I used a popular content distribution network). Just like the web-serving, the two other backend components had to be "horizontally scalable," which means that to support more users, and the associated compute and data, all I had to do was add more hardware, without any need to rewrite the backend software code, or perform excessive systems administration. This enabled me to scale fast in the early days, with minimal staff and financing. The second component, was a horizontally scalable game server framework called "Starburst", which was a work of love I created myself. This was built on top of an open source server that supported RTMP, an Adobe network protocol that allowed Flash media (remember that!!) assets running inside web browsers to directly talk to it. Starburst hosted game/social network logic and routed huge numbers of events being generated by the game to users in near realtime. The third component was a horizontally scalable NoSQL database called Cassandra (if you follow databases, you'll know that a modern derivative called ScyllaDB is currently doing well serving realtime AI needs). On my team, I had the only Cassandra core committer outside the company that built it. Further, I was the first serious party using the Cassandra beta in anger, and it got corrupted at 800,000 users, which was followed by a very testy 24 hours recovering the data, and bringing it back online (one moment I was going to the moon, the next moment I thought things had gone irreversibly wrong, but luckily things worked out). What was cool about Cassandra was that you could literally just add nodes (i.e. server machines with big hard drives installed) to horizontally scale its storage capacity, read throughput, and most importantly, its write throughput, which is very rare thing, and in my application absolutely crucial, because Fight My Monster generated a simply vast amount of data. Of course, another very important aspect of Cassandra was that it was fault tolerant, and I used a replication factor of 5, which meant everyone's data was very safe (or so I thought...). A replication factor of 5 meant I only needed nodes 3 online, for any specific "quorum of data," for it to be writable. Unlike a blockchain, Cassandra wasn't Byzantine Fault Tolerant, which meant that I had to manage the security of my infrastructure carefully to make sure hackers or malware didn't get in. But back then, hackers weren't interested in an MMO game/social network where most of the users were kids, and this wasn't supposed to be a general platform for others to build on. My main technical work pressure was just that the nodes hosting the database were under enormous strain owing to the amount of data being generated, and would therefore regularly blow up! This meant that I would have to login to my infra every so often, decommission broken nodes, and add new ones, which was easy enough, because the fault tolerance meant the job didn't have to be done immediately, and the "bare metal" machines involved could be orchestrated through my cloud provider... Fight My Monster used a setup years ahead of its time, and it allowed me to scale up with ease. Moreover, the fault tolerance, and the simple backend architecture with only 3 core system components, meant minimal administration and stress was involved in keeping it running. So what was the important lesson, which plays an important role in my thinking, and in ICP, to this day? You must surely have sensed that something crazy happened, and now I will share it publicly for the first time. I was traveling in Asia, as part of the "traveling circus" associated with the early core Ethereum community, visiting related parties (people often forget the importance of Asia, and China particularly, in helping support the early crypto scene) and attending Ethereum-related events, where I mainly talked about complex Computer Science techniques I had developed that I wanted to be used to make networks like Bitcoin and Ethereum scale and perform better. I don't want to drone on about "what is used to be like in crypto," but I will say that it was a magical time, and I owe a lot to early people for some amazing memories. It was also engaging, and I wasn't checking my email. Consequently, what I did not see on my travels, were email after email warning me of the fact that the credit card that was paying for Fight My Monster's Cassandra nodes had expired.... So what did the cloud operator do when I didn't respond within a few weeks (it wasn't many, but I forget the exact number). Well, they simply deleted all the nodes!!! It's hard to describe how I felt when I got back home to Palo Alto in California, and discovered what had happened. It was a mixture of shock and horror, a kind of hollow feeling in my stomach, adrenaline surges, and unfolding dread, as I worked as fast as I could to fix it, only to confirm that what had happened was irreversible. People who've been hacked in crypto will know the feeling. That was it. Fight My Monster was dead. Some part of the community even created a change dot org website pleading for it to be brought back online. Despite the loss of what it might have been worth, and the guilt, in some ways it was liberating, as I no longer had responsibility to maintain it, which probably would have done ad infinitum for the community. Plus it became a fond memory for a generation of kids and some adults that played it, before the game had a chance to grow too old and tired, and it allowed me to focus on what had become my obsession — decentralized compute networks. The lesson however was very clear to me. You can create decentralized compute infrastructure that can scale, and is fault tolerant, but if you have a single point of failure, anywhere, at any moment, it can be toast. That's why I'm always concerned when I hear about blockchains that depend on administrator keys held by the core devs, or blockchains that go down, or almost go down, when a huge chunk of their nodes are shutdown by a cloud running them, or because the cloud running them has technical problems. This problem of great fragility is vastly more prevalent than you might imagine in our industry. The learnings from the Fight My Monster disaster informed how the Internet Computer was designed. It's not only the number of nodes that matters, there are more important things. If nodes are anonymous, the number of independent parties running the bulk of them might be far less than you might think. Further, while large in number, they often turn out to be running on a small number of clouds— and even if they are owned and operated by a few different parties, the cloud might suddenly decide it doesn't want them anymore, and shut them down overnight, as Hetzner once did to a famous blockchain. What matters in practice is the number of independent parties running the nodes, and the physical and jurisdictional independence of the nodes. This simple insight is that was behind "deterministic decentralization," which will appear in new form inside the forthcoming "ICP cloud engines" extension of the Internet Computer. ICP cloud engines allow enterprises (typically) to create what is effectively an Internet Computer subnet whose configuration they themselves control, by choosing nodes to combine from a pool that acts as a marketplace. Currently there are more than 1.5k nodes waiting, and the number is growing. An engine provides a serverless cloud platform with remarkable properties. It is the ideal place for AI-built apps and services, because the has been stack designed to allow AI to generate advanced AIware software with ease, which AIware is secure and resilient. Apps are tamperproof (immune to infrastructure hacks), always-on (and thus incredibly resilient), optionally autonomous (which means there is no backdoor), digital assets native, and many other things. Engines also run e.g. the Open SaaS suite of AIware apps that can be used to run enterprises end-to-end. Cloud engines make installing and maintaining complex apps like Open CRM or Open Email as simple as installing and maintaining phone apps. Nodes are hot-swappable. That means you can change the compute replication factor, swap out the nodes for different ones, without interrupting what the cloud engine hosts, providing freedom from compute vendor lock-in, and, if you want, you can use a new class of nodes on hyperscalers, as well as traditional Internet Computer nodes, so it will function as a general compute marketplace. The cloud engine framework guides people to combine nodes that have independence, but provides flexibility that shared Internet Computer hosting doesn't have. For example, an enterprise in Germany might choose nodes that reside only in the EU, to meet GDPR requirements. However, the cloud engine console, which is autonomous, and served from the Internet Computer network, and updated by the NNS (the Network Nervous System, the world's most advanced DAO), guides users and warns them heavily if they combine nodes from the same node provider, or which are based in the same data center, say, or run by the same cloud operator. Thus, even with ICP cloud engines, the lessons of Fight My Monster live on. People will wonder why the framework pushes them so strongly to combine independent nodes, but there is a good reason, which is just as relevant for the wider blockchain community today, as it was in 2015. Looking forward to sharing cloud engines soon.
Show more
0
113
940
234
Forward to community
Per request, I’m sharing my thoughts on this week’s Torah portion today so people don’t miss it. I’ll be sharing it again tomorrow before Shabbat. 🙏 This week, we read the portion of Toldot. Toldot has to be one of the most dramatic portions in the whole Torah. Someone could literally make a movie about this portion, and it would be a hit at the box office. Thinking about what to write this week wasn’t a question of finding something. It was a question of choosing something. So many gems… The portion begins with a very strange verse. It says, “This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham. Abraham begot Isaac.” The Torah doesn’t waste words. That verse seems incredibly redundant. “This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham.” That’s how the verse should have ended. Why does the verse continue by telling us that Abraham was Isaac’s father? We just said that. Why the repetition? This is something that bothered many commentators on the Torah, and many answers have been given. I think there is an answer that is both simple and incredibly profound. You want to know someone’s nature? Want to know what they are really about? Show me where they came from. The story of Isaac is that Abraham was his father. Show me where you came from, and I’ll show you where you’re going. Isaac’s story begins with the fact that he was raised in the household of Abraham and Sarah. This lesson is absolutely crucial for today. We live in a world that seems to be becoming more and more immoral by the day. I believe that the source of the moral bankruptcy that we are witnessing across the world is the fact that people have forgotten where they came from, and so they don’t know where they’re going. The world today is obsessed with the future. It’s obsessed with advancing as fast as possible, but in doing so, in focusing exclusively on the future, too many people abandon their past. The verse is not redundant or repetitive. It is descriptive. Want to know Isaac’s story? Then remember where he came from. However, this idea has a flip side to it. Isaac was a righteous leader because he came from a righteous family and was brought up in a household of good deeds and kindness. However, in the very next verse, the Torah says, “Isaac was forty years old when he took to wife Rebekah, daughter of Bethuel the Aramean of Paddan-aram, sister of Laban the Aramean.” The same question: Why does the Torah tell us that Rebekah is the daughter of Bethuel from Paddan-aram? We already know this! In Rebekah’s case, her righteousness is not because of her upbringing; it is despite it. Rebekah grew up in a household that was anything but righteous. Her father was not exactly a good role model, and despite that, she grew up to be a kind woman who ended up marrying Isaac precisely because of her kindness. In her case, she looked at her father and realized she wanted a different path for herself. Where she came from also affected where she was going, but in the exact opposite way of Isaac. He was righteous because of his upbringing. She was righteous despite her upbringing. Which one is a greater accomplishment: becoming righteous when coming from righteousness or becoming righteous when coming from a lack of righteousness? Well, in the next verse, the Torah answers that question. The next verse says, “Isaac pleaded with GOD on behalf of his wife, because she was infertile; and GOD responded to his plea, and his wife Rebekah conceived.” Rebekah was infertile and was desperate for a child, but her prayers went unanswered. Then Isaac prayed for her, and his prayers were answered. The obvious question is why. Why did God not answer Rebekah’s prayers but answer Isaac’s? The commentary explains that Isaac’s prayers were answered while hers were rejected because there is no comparing a righteous person born to a righteous person to a righteous person born to an evil person. In other words, Isaac was on a higher level, and that’s why his prayers were answered. How strange! One would think it was the exact opposite! It’s easy for Isaac to be righteous because that’s all he ever saw growing up. All he had to do was follow in his father’s footsteps. Rebekah, on the other hand, had to work on herself to abandon the evil ways of her father and become righteous. You’d think she would be on a higher level! I heard a beautiful thought about this from Rabbi Goldberg. Isaac, who grew up in the shadow of Abraham, the father of monotheism, might have felt inadequate being around such a giant. He might have felt that there was no point in even trying because he could never live up to his father’s legacy. We even see this today. Some of the biggest rabbis have children who abandon Judaism because they give up trying, thinking they’ll never reach the greatness of their father. Rebekah grew up surrounded by evil. For her, the choice was more obvious. She saw the ways of her father and realized she needed to be different. In other words, it was harder for Isaac to be righteous and not just give up, while it was easier for Rebekah to recognize the evil ways of her father and rise above them. And here is where the drama begins. So Rebekah gets pregnant, and the pregnancy doesn’t go well. She is in extraordinary pain. The Torah says, “But the children struggled in her womb, and she said, ‘If so, why do I exist?’ She went to inquire of GOD.” And GOD answered her, “Two nations are in your womb, Two separate peoples shall issue from your body; One people shall be mightier than the other, And the older shall serve the younger.” So she is informed that she’s having twins and that they will be two leaders of two nations. The pain she was experiencing was due to the twins fighting, a fight that would transcend generations and continue to this very day. The Torah continues, “When her time to give birth was at hand, there were twins in her womb. The first one emerged red, like a hairy mantle all over; so they named him Esau. Then his brother emerged, holding on to the heel of Esau; so they named him Jacob. Isaac was sixty years old when they were born.” So Rebekah gives birth to the twins, the older one being Esau and the younger one, Jacob. As we know, Jacob grows up to be righteous while Esau grows up to be evil. What is the significance of their names, and why is Jacob named for the fact that he held on to his brother’s heel? Why is that important? The word Esau in Hebrew shares a root with the word Asuy, which means “done”! When ordering a steak, “Asuy tov” means “Well done”. (Don’t ever order a steak well done! 😁) Jacob shares a root with the word Akev, which means “heel.” Esau’s mentality was that what you see is what you get. He is “done.” He is complete. He is who he is. Jacob, on the other hand, like a heel, is always moving, always working, always improving himself. The significance of Jacob holding Esau’s heel is that he wanted to come out first. He wanted to be the firstborn. He wanted more. Jacob had a growth mindset, while Esau had a static mindset. That is why they grew up the way they did. Like a bicycle, if things are rough, it means you’re going uphill; you’re working on yourself. If things are easy, you’re going downhill and need to change direction. If you stand still, you will fall. Esau represents standing still. Jacob represents the constant climb. “If life is easy, you’re living it wrong.” — Ari Fuld This theme of the two brothers continues throughout their lives, with Jacob constantly striving for greater heights and Esau remaining stagnant. “When the boys grew up, Esau became a skillful hunter, a man of the outdoors; but Jacob became a mild man who stayed in camp. Once when Jacob was cooking a stew, Esau came in from the open, famished. And Esau said to Jacob, ‘Give me some of that red stuff to gulp down, for I am famished’—which is why he was named Edom. Jacob said, ‘First sell me your birthright.’ And Esau said, ‘I am at the point of death, so of what use is my birthright to me?’ But Jacob said, ‘Swear to me first.’ So he swore to him and sold his birthright to Jacob. Jacob then gave Esau bread and lentil stew; he ate and drank, and he rose and went away. Thus did Esau spurn the birthright.” Jacob, when asked by Esau to give him food, negotiated the food in exchange for the rights of the firstborn. Esau easily agreed and sold his birthright to Jacob in exchange for the food. Again, Jacob has ambitions, while Esau dismisses the importance of the birthright. To Esau, that didn’t matter. What mattered was his hunger in that moment, not the long-term vision. What happens next is one of the most controversial stories in the entire Torah. “When Isaac was old and his eyes were too dim to see, he called his older son Esau and said to him, ‘My son.’ He answered, ‘Here I am.’ And he said, ‘I am old now, and I do not know how soon I may die. Take your gear, your quiver and bow, and go out into the open and hunt me some game. Then prepare a dish for me such as I like, and bring it to me to eat, so that I may give you my innermost blessing before I die.’ Rebekah had been listening as Isaac spoke to his son Esau. When Esau had gone out into the open to hunt game to bring home, Rebekah said to her son Jacob, ‘I overheard your father speaking to your brother Esau, saying, “Bring me some game and prepare a dish for me to eat, that I may bless you, with GOD’s approval, before I die.” Now, my son, listen carefully as I instruct you. Go to the flock and fetch me two choice kids, and I will make of them a dish for your father, such as he likes. Then take it to your father to eat, in order that he may bless you before he dies.’” This is unbelievable. Isaac tells Esau to go hunt for food and bring it to him. Isaac tells Esau that he will bless him before he dies. Rebekah hears this and instructs Jacob to trick his dad, Isaac, and steal the blessing from Esau. She comes up with an elaborate plan for Jacob to disguise himself as Esau so Isaac won’t know it’s him and will fall for the trick. And that’s exactly what happens. Jacob disguises himself as Esau and tricks his dad, Isaac. But things almost fall apart when Isaac, who was blind, feels Jacob’s hand, which he had covered with hair to trick his dad, and says to him, “The hands are the hands of Esau, but the voice is the voice of Jacob.” “Isaac said to Jacob, ‘Come closer that I may feel you, my son—whether you are really my son Esau or not.’ So Jacob drew close to his father Isaac, who felt him and wondered, ‘The voice is the voice of Jacob, yet the hands are the hands of Esau.’ He did not recognize him, because his hands were hairy like those of his brother Esau; and so he blessed him.” This elaborate scheme to trick Isaac bothers literally all the commentators. How do we reconcile the fact that Rebekah, who is our matriarch, instructs her son to blatantly lie and trick her husband, his dad, Isaac? How are we to understand that Jacob agreed to trick his dad into thinking he was Esau in order to steal Esau’s blessing? What was Rebekah thinking? What was Jacob thinking? Why did he agree to lie to his dad? What is the significance of that line, “The voice is the voice of Jacob, but the hands are the hands of Esau”? Is there something deeper happening here? There must be. Rabbi Sacks discusses this. “Was Jacob right to take Esau’s blessing in disguise? Was he right to deceive his father and to take from his brother the blessing Isaac sought to give him? Was Rebecca right in conceiving the plan in the first place and encouraging Jacob to carry it out? These are fundamental questions.” Here is one way of interpreting the narrative. Rebecca was right to propose what she did, and Jacob was right to do it. Rebecca knew that it would be Jacob, not Esau, who would continue the covenant and carry the mission of Abraham into the future. Second, she had watched the twins grow up. She knew that Esau was a hunter, a man of violence. She had seen that he was impetuous, mercurial, a man of impulse, not calm reflection. She had seen him sell his birthright for a bowl of soup. She had watched while he “ate, drank, rose and left. So Esau despised his birthright.” No one who despises his birthright can be the trusted guardian of a covenant intended for eternity. Third, just before the episode of the blessing, we read: “When Esau was forty years old, he married Judith, daughter of Beeri the Hittite, and also Basemath, daughter of Elon the Hittite. They were a source of grief to Isaac and Rebecca.” This, too, was evidence of Esau’s failure to understand what the covenant requires. By marrying Hittite women, he proved himself indifferent both to the feelings of his parents and to the self-restraint in the choice of marriage partner that was essential to being Abraham’s heir. The blessing had to go to Jacob. If you had two sons, one indifferent to art, the other an art-lover and aesthete, to whom would you leave the Rembrandt that has been part of the family heritage for generations?” In other words, Rebekah knew that it was Jacob who was supposed to get that blessing, and she did her part in ensuring that it happened. So it was less about deception. It was more about correction. “This was, after all, not just a matter of relationships within the family. It was about God and destiny and spiritual vocation. It was about the future of an entire people since God had repeatedly told Abraham that he would be the ancestor of a great nation who would be a blessing to humanity as a whole. And if Rebecca was right, then Jacob was right to follow her instructions.” “This was the woman whom Abraham’s servant had chosen to be the wife of his master’s son, because she was kind, because at the well she had given water to a stranger and to his camels also. Rebecca was not Lady Macbeth, acting out of favouritism or ambition. She was the embodiment of loving-kindness. And if she had no other way of ensuring that the blessing went to one who would cherish it and live it, then in this case the end justified the means. This is one way of reading the story and it is taken by many of the commentators.” Brilliant. My friend Shui Haber wrote something beautiful about this story, specifically the words “The voice is the voice of Jacob, but the hands are the hands of Esau.” “Lately I have been thinking about double standards. Everyone runs into them, and holds a few of their own. I have always been something of a nonconformist, and double standards frustrate me, even when I catch them in myself. The ones that bother me most live in the gap between the person we show the world and the person we actually are. We build a persona, and underneath it there is a human being. Both are real, and yet they often disagree. Yaakov dresses up as someone else to get a brachah. Why does it have to happen this way? Yaakov wears Esav’s clothes and puts Esav’s clothing on his hands when he goes in to his father. Yitzchak feels him and says, ‘Hakol kol Yaakov vehayadayim yedei Esav.’ The voice belongs to Yaakov, and the hands belong to Esav. This has always bothered me. We are supposed to be authentic and true to ourselves, yet Yaakov receives his father’s bracha in a costume.” Shui talks about the personal struggle everyone faces when striving to be one way but sometimes not living up to that expectation. “The longer I think about it, the less sure I am that every gap between the inside and the outside amounts to dishonesty. A person can sincerely believe in a standard with his whole heart and still struggle to live by it. The wanting is part of who he is too. Falling short of the standard leaves the desire just as real as it was before.” “Rav Dov Zinger suggests that Yitzchak always intended the material blessings for Esav and birkas Avraham for Yaakov, which he later gives Yaakov knowingly. Rivka believes Yaakov should receive both. In her eyes, Yaakov can carry Avraham’s legacy and build in the physical world at the same time. The voice of Yaakov and the hands of Esav can belong to one person, and the disguise brings that combination before Yitzchak.” In other words, Rebekah wanted both blessings to go to Jacob and not Esau: the blessing Isaac originally intended for Jacob and also the blessing originally intended for Esau. “Even so, I keep coming back to those hands. Why must they remain the hands of Esav? When do they become Yaakov’s own?” “The person beneath the persona is also the person who put it on. Somewhere in that complicated relationship between who we are and who we are reaching to become, something authentic is taking place. Yaakov’s voice remains his own beneath the costume. Can we envision a day when our hands will be our own as well, when the hands of Yaakov will no longer need to look like someone else’s? Can we picture the day we receive the brachah as ourselves?” It’s a beautiful thought that very much resonated with me. As mentioned, this whole episode of Jacob stealing Esau’s blessing from Isaac bothered all the commentators on the Torah, and justifiably so. It’s hard to believe and understand if we view our patriarchs and matriarchs as perfectly righteous people. Perhaps the answer is not so complicated after all, perhaps it is much simpler. Rebekah and Jacob are human beings, and they make human mistakes. Rabbi Sacks says, “There is such a thing as an honest mistake, and it is a mark of Jacob’s greatness that he recognised it and made amends to Esau. That is how the moral life is. We learn by making mistakes. We live life forward, but we understand it only looking back. Only then do we see the wrong turns we inadvertently made. This discovery is sometimes our greatest moment of moral truth. For each of us there is a blessing that is ours. That was true not just of Isaac but also Ishmael, not just Jacob but also Esau. The moral could not be more powerful. Never seek your brother’s blessing. Be content with your own.” This whole episode affected Jacob’s story and continued to affect Jacob’s descendants throughout the generations until today when Esau and his descendants continue to hate and persecute Jacob’s descendants, the Jewish people. Whatever the explanation is as to why Rebekah did what she did and why Jacob agreed to do what he did, the bottom line for us is that we should all be more like Jacob and continue to strive to reach greater heights and not like Esau who was happy in his current state and had zero ambitions to grow. We should all aim to climb the hill on our own individual bicycles but try not to do so at the expense of others. Shabbat shalom.
Show more
Signing off for 25+ hours of family time away from all ringing, pinging, and tweeting devices! Best time of the week! This week, we read the portion of Toldot. Toldot has to be one of the most dramatic portions in the whole Torah. Someone could literally make a movie about this portion, and it would be a hit at the box office. Thinking about what to write this week wasn’t a question of finding something. It was a question of choosing something. So many gems… The portion begins with a very strange verse. It says, “This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham. Abraham begot Isaac.” The Torah doesn’t waste words. That verse seems incredibly redundant. “This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham.” That’s how the verse should have ended. Why does the verse continue by telling us that Abraham was Isaac’s father? We just said that. Why the repetition? This is something that bothered many commentators on the Torah, and many answers have been given. I think there is an answer that is both simple and incredibly profound. You want to know someone’s nature? Want to know what they are really about? Show me where they came from. The story of Isaac is that Abraham was his father. Show me where you came from, and I’ll show you where you’re going. Isaac’s story begins with the fact that he was raised in the household of Abraham and Sarah. This lesson is absolutely crucial for today. We live in a world that seems to be becoming more and more immoral by the day. I believe that the source of the moral bankruptcy that we are witnessing across the world is the fact that people have forgotten where they came from, and so they don’t know where they’re going. The world today is obsessed with the future. It’s obsessed with advancing as fast as possible, but in doing so, in focusing exclusively on the future, too many people abandon their past. The verse is not redundant or repetitive. It is descriptive. Want to know Isaac’s story? Then remember where he came from. However, this idea has a flip side to it. Isaac was a righteous leader because he came from a righteous family and was brought up in a household of good deeds and kindness. However, in the very next verse, the Torah says, “Isaac was forty years old when he took to wife Rebekah, daughter of Bethuel the Aramean of Paddan-aram, sister of Laban the Aramean.” The same question: Why does the Torah tell us that Rebekah is the daughter of Bethuel from Paddan-aram? We already know this! In Rebekah’s case, her righteousness is not because of her upbringing; it is despite it. Rebekah grew up in a household that was anything but righteous. Her father was not exactly a good role model, and despite that, she grew up to be a kind woman who ended up marrying Isaac precisely because of her kindness. In her case, she looked at her father and realized she wanted a different path for herself. Where she came from also affected where she was going, but in the exact opposite way of Isaac. He was righteous because of his upbringing. She was righteous despite her upbringing. Which one is a greater accomplishment: becoming righteous when coming from righteousness or becoming righteous when coming from a lack of righteousness? Well, in the next verse, the Torah answers that question. The next verse says, “Isaac pleaded with GOD on behalf of his wife, because she was infertile; and GOD responded to his plea, and his wife Rebekah conceived.” Rebekah was infertile and was desperate for a child, but her prayers went unanswered. Then Isaac prayed for her, and his prayers were answered. The obvious question is why. Why did God not answer Rebekah’s prayers but answer Isaac’s? The commentary explains that Isaac’s prayers were answered while hers were rejected because there is no comparing a righteous person born to a righteous person to a righteous person born to an evil person. In other words, Isaac was on a higher level, and that’s why his prayers were answered. How strange! One would think it was the exact opposite! It’s easy for Isaac to be righteous because that’s all he ever saw growing up. All he had to do was follow in his father’s footsteps. Rebekah, on the other hand, had to work on herself to abandon the evil ways of her father and become righteous. You’d think she would be on a higher level! I heard a beautiful thought about this from Rabbi Goldberg. Isaac, who grew up in the shadow of Abraham, the father of monotheism, might have felt inadequate being around such a giant. He might have felt that there was no point in even trying because he could never live up to his father’s legacy. We even see this today. Some of the biggest rabbis have children who abandon Judaism because they give up trying, thinking they’ll never reach the greatness of their father. Rebekah grew up surrounded by evil. For her, the choice was more obvious. She saw the ways of her father and realized she needed to be different. In other words, it was harder for Isaac to be righteous and not just give up, while it was easier for Rebekah to recognize the evil ways of her father and rise above them. And here is where the drama begins. So Rebekah gets pregnant, and the pregnancy doesn’t go well. She is in extraordinary pain. The Torah says, “But the children struggled in her womb, and she said, ‘If so, why do I exist?’ She went to inquire of GOD.” And GOD answered her, “Two nations are in your womb, Two separate peoples shall issue from your body; One people shall be mightier than the other, And the older shall serve the younger.” So she is informed that she’s having twins and that they will be two leaders of two nations. The pain she was experiencing was due to the twins fighting, a fight that would transcend generations and continue to this very day. The Torah continues, “When her time to give birth was at hand, there were twins in her womb. The first one emerged red, like a hairy mantle all over; so they named him Esau. Then his brother emerged, holding on to the heel of Esau; so they named him Jacob. Isaac was sixty years old when they were born.” So Rebekah gives birth to the twins, the older one being Esau and the younger one, Jacob. As we know, Jacob grows up to be righteous while Esau grows up to be evil. What is the significance of their names, and why is Jacob named for the fact that he held on to his brother’s heel? Why is that important? The word Esau in Hebrew shares a root with the word Asuy, which means “done”! When ordering a steak, “Asuy tov” means “Well done”. (Don’t ever order a steak well done! 😁) Jacob shares a root with the word Akev, which means “heel.” Esau’s mentality was that what you see is what you get. He is “done.” He is complete. He is who he is. Jacob, on the other hand, like a heel, is always moving, always working, always improving himself. The significance of Jacob holding Esau’s heel is that he wanted to come out first. He wanted to be the firstborn. He wanted more. Jacob had a growth mindset, while Esau had a static mindset. That is why they grew up the way they did. Like a bicycle, if things are rough, it means you’re going uphill; you’re working on yourself. If things are easy, you’re going downhill and need to change direction. If you stand still, you will fall. Esau represents standing still. Jacob represents the constant climb. “If life is easy, you’re living it wrong.” — Ari Fuld This theme of the two brothers continues throughout their lives, with Jacob constantly striving for greater heights and Esau remaining stagnant. “When the boys grew up, Esau became a skillful hunter, a man of the outdoors; but Jacob became a mild man who stayed in camp. Once when Jacob was cooking a stew, Esau came in from the open, famished. And Esau said to Jacob, ‘Give me some of that red stuff to gulp down, for I am famished’—which is why he was named Edom. Jacob said, ‘First sell me your birthright.’ And Esau said, ‘I am at the point of death, so of what use is my birthright to me?’ But Jacob said, ‘Swear to me first.’ So he swore to him and sold his birthright to Jacob. Jacob then gave Esau bread and lentil stew; he ate and drank, and he rose and went away. Thus did Esau spurn the birthright.” Jacob, when asked by Esau to give him food, negotiated the food in exchange for the rights of the firstborn. Esau easily agreed and sold his birthright to Jacob in exchange for the food. Again, Jacob has ambitions, while Esau dismisses the importance of the birthright. To Esau, that didn’t matter. What mattered was his hunger in that moment, not the long-term vision. What happens next is one of the most controversial stories in the entire Torah. “When Isaac was old and his eyes were too dim to see, he called his older son Esau and said to him, ‘My son.’ He answered, ‘Here I am.’ And he said, ‘I am old now, and I do not know how soon I may die. Take your gear, your quiver and bow, and go out into the open and hunt me some game. Then prepare a dish for me such as I like, and bring it to me to eat, so that I may give you my innermost blessing before I die.’ Rebekah had been listening as Isaac spoke to his son Esau. When Esau had gone out into the open to hunt game to bring home, Rebekah said to her son Jacob, ‘I overheard your father speaking to your brother Esau, saying, “Bring me some game and prepare a dish for me to eat, that I may bless you, with GOD’s approval, before I die.” Now, my son, listen carefully as I instruct you. Go to the flock and fetch me two choice kids, and I will make of them a dish for your father, such as he likes. Then take it to your father to eat, in order that he may bless you before he dies.’” This is unbelievable. Isaac tells Esau to go hunt for food and bring it to him. Isaac tells Esau that he will bless him before he dies. Rebekah hears this and instructs Jacob to trick his dad, Isaac, and steal the blessing from Esau. She comes up with an elaborate plan for Jacob to disguise himself as Esau so Isaac won’t know it’s him and will fall for the trick. And that’s exactly what happens. Jacob disguises himself as Esau and tricks his dad, Isaac. But things almost fall apart when Isaac, who was blind, feels Jacob’s hand, which he had covered with hair to trick his dad, and says to him, “The hands are the hands of Esau, but the voice is the voice of Jacob.” “Isaac said to Jacob, ‘Come closer that I may feel you, my son—whether you are really my son Esau or not.’ So Jacob drew close to his father Isaac, who felt him and wondered, ‘The voice is the voice of Jacob, yet the hands are the hands of Esau.’ He did not recognize him, because his hands were hairy like those of his brother Esau; and so he blessed him.” This elaborate scheme to trick Isaac bothers literally all the commentators. How do we reconcile the fact that Rebekah, who is our matriarch, instructs her son to blatantly lie and trick her husband, his dad, Isaac? How are we to understand that Jacob agreed to trick his dad into thinking he was Esau in order to steal Esau’s blessing? What was Rebekah thinking? What was Jacob thinking? Why did he agree to lie to his dad? What is the significance of that line, “The voice is the voice of Jacob, but the hands are the hands of Esau”? Is there something deeper happening here? There must be. Rabbi Sacks discusses this. “Was Jacob right to take Esau’s blessing in disguise? Was he right to deceive his father and to take from his brother the blessing Isaac sought to give him? Was Rebecca right in conceiving the plan in the first place and encouraging Jacob to carry it out? These are fundamental questions.” Here is one way of interpreting the narrative. Rebecca was right to propose what she did, and Jacob was right to do it. Rebecca knew that it would be Jacob, not Esau, who would continue the covenant and carry the mission of Abraham into the future. Second, she had watched the twins grow up. She knew that Esau was a hunter, a man of violence. She had seen that he was impetuous, mercurial, a man of impulse, not calm reflection. She had seen him sell his birthright for a bowl of soup. She had watched while he “ate, drank, rose and left. So Esau despised his birthright.” No one who despises his birthright can be the trusted guardian of a covenant intended for eternity. Third, just before the episode of the blessing, we read: “When Esau was forty years old, he married Judith, daughter of Beeri the Hittite, and also Basemath, daughter of Elon the Hittite. They were a source of grief to Isaac and Rebecca.” This, too, was evidence of Esau’s failure to understand what the covenant requires. By marrying Hittite women, he proved himself indifferent both to the feelings of his parents and to the self-restraint in the choice of marriage partner that was essential to being Abraham’s heir. The blessing had to go to Jacob. If you had two sons, one indifferent to art, the other an art-lover and aesthete, to whom would you leave the Rembrandt that has been part of the family heritage for generations?” In other words, Rebekah knew that it was Jacob who was supposed to get that blessing, and she did her part in ensuring that it happened. So it was less about deception. It was more about correction. “This was, after all, not just a matter of relationships within the family. It was about God and destiny and spiritual vocation. It was about the future of an entire people since God had repeatedly told Abraham that he would be the ancestor of a great nation who would be a blessing to humanity as a whole. And if Rebecca was right, then Jacob was right to follow her instructions.” “This was the woman whom Abraham’s servant had chosen to be the wife of his master’s son, because she was kind, because at the well she had given water to a stranger and to his camels also. Rebecca was not Lady Macbeth, acting out of favouritism or ambition. She was the embodiment of loving-kindness. And if she had no other way of ensuring that the blessing went to one who would cherish it and live it, then in this case the end justified the means. This is one way of reading the story and it is taken by many of the commentators.” Brilliant. My friend Shui Haber wrote something beautiful about this story, specifically the words “The voice is the voice of Jacob, but the hands are the hands of Esau.” “Lately I have been thinking about double standards. Everyone runs into them, and holds a few of their own. I have always been something of a nonconformist, and double standards frustrate me, even when I catch them in myself. The ones that bother me most live in the gap between the person we show the world and the person we actually are. We build a persona, and underneath it there is a human being. Both are real, and yet they often disagree. Yaakov dresses up as someone else to get a brachah. Why does it have to happen this way? Yaakov wears Esav’s clothes and puts Esav’s clothing on his hands when he goes in to his father. Yitzchak feels him and says, ‘Hakol kol Yaakov vehayadayim yedei Esav.’ The voice belongs to Yaakov, and the hands belong to Esav. This has always bothered me. We are supposed to be authentic and true to ourselves, yet Yaakov receives his father’s bracha in a costume.” Shui talks about the personal struggle everyone faces when striving to be one way but sometimes not living up to that expectation. “The longer I think about it, the less sure I am that every gap between the inside and the outside amounts to dishonesty. A person can sincerely believe in a standard with his whole heart and still struggle to live by it. The wanting is part of who he is too. Falling short of the standard leaves the desire just as real as it was before.” “Rav Dov Zinger suggests that Yitzchak always intended the material blessings for Esav and birkas Avraham for Yaakov, which he later gives Yaakov knowingly. Rivka believes Yaakov should receive both. In her eyes, Yaakov can carry Avraham’s legacy and build in the physical world at the same time. The voice of Yaakov and the hands of Esav can belong to one person, and the disguise brings that combination before Yitzchak.” In other words, Rebekah wanted both blessings to go to Jacob and not Esau: the blessing Isaac originally intended for Jacob and also the blessing originally intended for Esau. “Even so, I keep coming back to those hands. Why must they remain the hands of Esav? When do they become Yaakov’s own?” “The person beneath the persona is also the person who put it on. Somewhere in that complicated relationship between who we are and who we are reaching to become, something authentic is taking place. Yaakov’s voice remains his own beneath the costume. Can we envision a day when our hands will be our own as well, when the hands of Yaakov will no longer need to look like someone else’s? Can we picture the day we receive the brachah as ourselves?” It’s a beautiful thought that very much resonated with me. As mentioned, this whole episode of Jacob stealing Esau’s blessing from Isaac bothered all the commentators on the Torah, and justifiably so. It’s hard to believe and understand if we view our patriarchs and matriarchs as perfectly righteous people. Perhaps the answer is not so complicated after all, perhaps it is much simpler. Rebekah and Jacob are human beings, and they make human mistakes. Rabbi Sacks says, “There is such a thing as an honest mistake, and it is a mark of Jacob’s greatness that he recognised it and made amends to Esau. That is how the moral life is. We learn by making mistakes. We live life forward, but we understand it only looking back. Only then do we see the wrong turns we inadvertently made. This discovery is sometimes our greatest moment of moral truth. For each of us there is a blessing that is ours. That was true not just of Isaac but also Ishmael, not just Jacob but also Esau. The moral could not be more powerful. Never seek your brother’s blessing. Be content with your own.” This whole episode affected Jacob’s story and continued to affect Jacob’s descendants throughout the generations until today when Esau and his descendants continue to hate and persecute Jacob’s descendants, the Jewish people. Whatever the explanation is as to why Rebekah did what she did and why Jacob agreed to do what he did, the bottom line for us is that we should all be more like Jacob and continue to strive to reach greater heights and not like Esau who was happy in his current state and had zero ambitions to grow. We should all aim to climb the hill on our own individual bicycles but try not to do so at the expense of others. Shabbat shalom.
Show more
Fifteen years ago, under a cloudless Afghan sky and the crushing heat of the Helmand sun, Captain Ryan Cohen stood before his Marines of Kilo Company, 3rd Battalion, 7th Marines. The air was dry, the dirt baked hard, and every man there knew they were about to step deep into Taliban-controlled territory. Cohen didn’t give them some polished, ceremonial speech. He spoke like a man about to fight alongside them—and he was. He told them about fear, sadness, and regret. He didn’t pretend those feelings didn’t exist—he warned them they would come for you if you let them. Then his voice turned like steel: “The enemy is not ten feet tall—they’re four-foot-two, they’ve got a short reach, and you’re gonna fuck them up.” He told them to be methodical. To move with precision. To expect the unexpected—and when it came, to destroy it without hesitation. He gave them the rule that would outlive the fight: “Don’t let fear get inside that head of yours.” What seemed like moments later, the Marines of Kilo Company stepped off, and Afghanistan exploded around them. Machine-gun fire, mortars, and chaos—and Cohen was in the middle of it, moving through enemy fire, pulling Marines forward, and leading from the front. His actions that day, and on countless others, broke the enemy and lifted his Marines through hell. Today, Cohen wears the silver eagle of a Colonel. The days of gripping a rifle in the dust are behind him, but the words he gave that morning still stalk the ranks of the Marine Corps. Young Marines—many who were just kids when he spoke them—still repeat those lines before their own battles. Because that speech wasn’t just for one fight—it was a battle standard. A reminder that fear dies when you refuse to give it space, and that no matter what stands in front of you, it’s never ten feet tall. Repeating him in his Mickey Goldmill voice, deep within the Hundu Kush Mountains of Afghanistan in 2005,
Show more
the destruction of American education over the past decade is an incredible self-own competence is objective. a child can either do the math or they can’t. but in the u.s., a lot of people have reasons not to say that! parents don’t want to hear their kid is struggling. teachers don’t want scores used to manage them. districts don’t want embarrassment. progressives worry accountability will create inequity. conservatives don’t want federal authorities. so we end up with process, weak standards, and excuses to explain away bad outcomes. people object that it’s phones, covid, demographic change. ok! but we fail globally when others have phones, covid too — vietnam is much poorer than the u.s., yet performs well in international math comparisons. some countries treat math as a basic skill everyone needs to master. here, it is part of a fight about fairness, autonomy, and feelings in the age of AI — if people can’t do basic math, read closely, or think through problems, ai won’t make them more capable. it will become something they rely on without understanding. the countries that come out ahead in the global race won’t just have better technology. they’ll have people who know how to use it, question it, build on it. we need the national ability to decide something is worth doing coherently (teaching math!) the US has the money to teach math well but it has not shown the will. we are failing the next generation
Show more
0
103
850
118
Forward to community
Spencer Pratt on why he’s running for LA Mayor: “I’m doing this to fight evil, and evil has taken this beautiful city…” Friedberg: “ You're sitting down with your sons and they're saying, ‘Dad, what did you do to save LA?’ What do you tell them?” Spencer Pratt: “So to my sons, I'm showing them you can fight evil. These people are evil that let every innocent person that pays their taxes feel unsafe on their streets that they pay taxes for. A lot of people don't have money to do things because they pay all their taxes, like me, and then the city and the government fails them. And whether your house burns down or you’ve got a screaming drug addict in front of you, a naked drug addict in front of your kids causing trauma… there's people having literal drug addicts having sex on meth in front of kids. Parents are telling me they have to have their kids glued to an iPad in the backseat of their cars driving them to school. In other communities, they have to walk under these underpasses and walk past this. So I'll be able to tell my sons, thank God America had laws, and your dad said, 'Hey, breaking news, let's enforce them.' And we did it, and it worked, and then people came in with tons of money, and we got businesses booming, more jobs. Hollywood, we’re making even better movies than we've made in 10 years because the independent creative artists are inspired again. They're feeling supported. The vision is so real, and that's my fight. I go back to, if God is burning somebody's house down to fight these people, you're burning my house down, and then you burn my mom's house down, and you have me listening to my crying mom every day for 18 months. I do this to fight evil, and this is evil that has taken this beautiful city” @friedberg @spencerpratt --------------------------------------- Thanks to our partner for making this possible Most advertisers have never heard of the platform with an $11B annual run rate in ad spend. by AppLovin — 1B+ daily active users, full-screen video ads watched for a median of 35 seconds, and businesses are profitably spending hundreds of thousands of dollars a day on it. Advertiser access is in closed beta. The window is open at @AxonAdsManager
Show more
0
31
1.3K
149
Forward to community
I’m sorry if this hurts some feelings but when people ask me how I feel about other countries… …I genuinely just don’t care I don’t care about Ukraine. I don’t care about Israel. I just don’t care. I’ve got 3 kids and everything is 10x more expensive than I was growing up, my grocery bill looks like a car payment and the car payment looks like a mortgage and my friends can't even get a mortgage because rent eats half their paycheck and now health insurance costs more than college used to and college costs more than a house used to, and a house costs more than a small private island used to, and utilities just keep going up they never go down, car insurance keeps going up, home insurance never goes down, every single freaking thing in life is now a subscription and you can't get rid of them, and every home repair now costs $5,000 for some reason and every company that does home repairs is one gigantic company so you either pay them what they want or your roof caves in, and I can't keep up with what AI is doing but I know it's important and that I should keep up because my friends keep getting laid off of their jobs "because of AI" but no one knows which jobs are safe from AI so everyone is panicking and side hustling just in case they are laid off, and telling their kids to skip college because there "won't be those jobs in the future" but everyone is still going to college like there will be and coming out with hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt and I'm terrified that my kids won't ever be able to afford a home of their own and thinking back to the days when my parents raised us on one income with a house and a yard and a vacation of some kind every summer, and everyone I know is working their butts off and then some just to stay afloat, and by the time the kids are in bed and the dishes are done and I finally sit down, I don’t have the energy left to care about anything happening on the other side of the world, because I’m barely keeping up with what’s happening on this side of my own front door… So no, I don’t have room in my heart for another country and their problems. I'm so sorry... I just don't anymore. And I wish, I WISH, our leaders would fight for us half as hard as they fight for everyone else.
Show more
0
515
5.4K
822
Forward to community