David Eby’s latest harebrained idea is to issue zero-interest loans to businesses in British Columbia. 💸
He’s basically turning taxpayers into lenders — competing with commercial banks. 🏦
Two ✌️ problems:
First, the province doesn’t have the money.
It has to go to the bond market, borrow that money at 4.5%, and then turn around and lend it out at 0.0%. 🤯
That’s a negative-carry loan book.
On $500 million, that’s $135 million in interest costs alone, over six years. 💰🔥
Then there’s default risk.
Banks are professional lenders.
They understand the number-one rule: lend money to people who will pay you back.
Government lending has a very different track record.
COVID loans had default rates exceeding 7% — 20x higher than what commercial banks typically experience. 📉
That same default rate would put another $35 million of taxpayers’ money in the furnace. 🔥
Add it together, and taxpayers are looking at a cost of $170 million — before administration costs. 🧾
Borrow at 4.5%.
Lend at 0%.
And taxpayers take the credit risk. 🎲
I guess David Eby is our banker now. 🏦
What could possibly go wrong? 🤷♂️