From
@chudson on why signaling risk from multi-stage firms doesn't exist anymore:
"When I first started Precursor, we were in the "founders should beware of multi-stage funds” signaling era.
Most seed funds had enough experience with companies backed by multi-stage funds at seed failing to clear the Series A bar, oftentimes with the firm that had done the seed declining to lead the A.
And people are like, “Oh, you’re gonna get signaling risk if you take the money.” I’m like, “Well, it’s only a signal if you don’t raise money. And you’re probably only gonna not raise money if you’re bad relative to what else is in that company’s funnel.”
This argument carried the day from, say 2010 through maybe 2017-'18. Most founders were like, “I’m open to the idea that taking a seed check from these multi-stage funds is not great for my business.”
And then it flipped. And I think it was really driven by repeat founders who were just like, “I know the bar at those funds. If I can’t clear it, whether I have their money or not, I don’t care. Their lack of willingness to fund me is a signal of quality, and I can deal with it.”
And I think it eroded this argument that multi-stage funds shouldn’t play at Seed. Because we’d gone through this cycle where multi-stage funds would dabble in seed.
They’d create a lot of ill will from founders who they didn’t follow on. And they’d pull back, and they’d be like, “You know, we should just leave this to the seed people.”
In a world where AUM is the name of the game... and I’d like to point out that a16z, the firm with the most AUM in our industry, is less than twenty-years old. In less than two decades, they’ve gone from nonexistent to the largest firm by AUM.
At some point, if you’re gonna grow AUM, the only way you can do it, if you believe that each of your individual strategies has a different elasticity, you have to be in every asset class.
So at some point, the multi-stage folks said, “You know, if we’re really gonna be a tip-to-tail multi-stage VC fund, we actually cannot allow someone else to just do seed for us. We have to have our own product in the market that competes with what they have.”
There’s an AUM opportunity here. But there’s also a full lifecycle pipeline opportunity. And their decision to come in, in a permanent way, I do think changed seed."