Surprised there hasn’t been more debate on Vitalik’s ETH-as-SoV post. It’s the biggest shift in ETH’s value narrative since “ultrasound money.”
Five questions it raises for me:
1/ Is a deflationary ETH off the table for good? Bitcoin faces a long-term security budget problem; ETH’s answer is perpetual issuance, i.e. permanent inflation. Will SoV investors accept that trade?
2/ SoV needs a credible monetary commitment. BTC’s case rests on a supply schedule nobody can change. ETH has no hard cap and an issuance curve still up for debate. If SoV is the goal, the next step is committing to a monetary policy, including a minimum issuance level.
3/ Native RWA issuance on L1 is pitched as a key driver, but it sits awkwardly with a more conservative L1 roadmap. Issuers go where users, liquidity and performance are, not where capital sits idle. If L1 stays ossified, why issue there instead of an L2?
4/ SoV is a social contract. It takes years to build and competes head-on with Bitcoin. What metrics would show it’s working, without handwaving?
5/ If survival is the first SoV metric, the quantum transition stops being a roadmap item. It becomes the top priority, and it needs a real timeline.
Thoughts
@ethlabs_org @ethereumfndn @fundstrat @ethereumJoseph
Expanding on why I believe "ETH as store of value (SoV)" makes much more sense to focus on than "ETH as fee-burning token".
Three primary reasons:
1. ETH as fee-burning token never was as strong as it seemed
2. Optimizing for ETH as fee-burning token would demand Ethereum and ETH function in ways that are very hard to make compatible with decentralization and capture resistance.
3. Meanwhile, optimizing for ETH as SoV is aligned with Ethereum focusing on its unique strengths (decentralization and CROPS)
EIP-1559 (including its burn) is fine and good, we should keep them. But we should not feel sad if fee burn is < 10% of breakeven indefinitely; the value of ETH comes from elsewhere.
The core idea: the big thing that people appreciate about Ethereum is decentralization and CROPS. The main pragmatic benefit that these things translate into is stability. SoV is the category where that is not an unneeded extra we merely put effort into for ideological reasons, but rather a pragmatic strength from the perspective of people putting in their assets. And in the era of AI disruption, stability will be highly valued.
Show more