The no. 1 question I’m getting about the HW4 retrofit is “omg why did it require a new windshield??!” The answer may surprise you: it didn’t. I hadn’t planned to replace it, but the original broke, and a Highland windshield was the easiest way forward. Details below.
The obvious differences between the HW3 and HW4 forward-facing cameras are their number and size. HW4 uses 2 larger cameras + 1 placeholder; HW3 is an integrated unit of 3 cameras with much smaller sensors. HW4 also has a completely different mounting-hole pattern.
But the real problem was the size and placement of the temperature/humidity and light sensors. The HW4 sensors wouldn’t fit in the HW3 frame, and the HW4 frame wouldn’t fit the HW3 windshield because of the light sensor cutout’s location.
My plan: 3D-scan both frames, then design and print one that fits the HW3 windshield, accommodates the HW4 sensors, and accepts the HW4 outer shell. No glass changes. Solid plan, and relatively simple, too.
One day later, I’m driving on a freeway when a rock shoots out from under some truck’s tire and cracks my windshield.
Not exactly pleasant, but a week later, my Tesla was rocking a Highland windshield with its stock HW4 frame and heaters. No going back now.
Luckily, the unbeatable
@Tutrifour had already shipped me a full set of Highland windshield and interior cameras, plus the rear-view mirror assembly. After giving the adhesive a day to cure, I started installing everything. A 15-minute job, surely. You would not believe just how wrong I was.
The windshield unit included its original harness, running from the cameras and sensors to the lower A-pillar connectors. I swapped the stock harness for it to avoid squeezing FAKRA-Z adapters into the cramped windshield assembly or cutting keying tabs off aluminum connectors.
One of the worst decisions of the entire project.
Only after laying out the whole harness did I discover that Tesla engineers, likely just for teh lulz, had swapped the male and female sides of the quad mini-FAKRA connectors in the lower A-pillar. As planned, no adapters under the windshield. Bonus: two harness halves I couldn’t physically connect.
Many cut coax cables and even more swearing later (crimping RG58 connectors will do that), the new cameras were connected to the computer. And they didn’t work 🙃
I’ll spare you the investigation details. Let’s play a game instead! You’re interviewing for an electrical engineer role at Tesla, working on the Model 3 Highland refresh.
The old Model 3 has 4 cameras on the windshield and a GPS antenna. Its harness splits in the lower A-pillar: the cameras share a quad mini-FAKRA connector; GPS gets a separate full-size FAKRA. Nothing unusual.
The refresh has one fewer camera, so one fewer cable. Your first task: redesign the wiring. What do you do?
If you said “leave one position in the quad connector unpopulated to keep things simple,” congratulations — you failed your Tesla interview. That’s not wrong; it’s just the tip of the iceberg.
The only valid answer: “Leave one position unpopulated, randomly shuffle all the connections, move the main camera to the separate full-size connector (keeping the same FAKRA key and color), and put GPS where the main camera used to be. Oh, and swap the male and female sides and change the keying so no sane person could even think about retrofitting this stuff.”
I’ll refrain from commenting on that.
Fun fact: the Highland windshield harness is much larger than the old one. There was no way to click the headliner into place without completely covering the interior cam. Cutting off a large piece of the interior trim is one of the things that definitely weren’t on my bingo card for this project.