John McWhorter On Jason Arday: Cambridge "chose a black person with no concern for excellence." Simon & Schuster "should have pity on someone who looks so ridiculous and incompetent."
I spoke with
@NYTOpinion columnist and
@Columbia linguist John McWhorter
@JohnHMcWhorter for my
@FreeBeacon article about Simon & Schuster's 11th-hour edits to his memoir:
Benjamin Ryan: Is there anything you could say that would speak to this question of Arday’s suitability for the rigors of academia, and in particular those demanded of a professor at an elite institution?
John McWhorter: It is revoltingly common for black academics to be received as if their mere presence is more important than what they actually have to contribute to general discussion. Arday was a classic example.
BR: Given what you’ve long said about affirmative action, what does this Greek tragedy of a tale tell us about what this system of preferential admissions, hiring and promotion has done to the overall integrity of academia?
JM: It's a perfect example of how the Latinate term "Affirmative Action" is a euphemism for lowering standards. It wasn't that Cambridge resisted some general tendency to only see excellence in whites. They chose a black person with no concern for excellence. In truth, they consider black people cognitively inferior.
BR: How has Arday’s precipitous fall harmed academia and harmed other black academics, who might have to live in this man’s shadow?
JM: I'm not sure he is significant in that way. Ardays are sadly common in academia. Not as extreme as him, but anyone in the humanities or social sciences can't help noticing that black people are admitted under different standards. No one is encountering this for the first time in him.
BR: What does it say that 11th-hour edits suggest that the publisher knew that there were brewing questions about Arday’s academic integrity and personal honesty and sought to mitigate how much the book could contribute to those accusations?
JW: That they have not cancelled the book dehumanizes Arday. They should have pity on someone who looks so ridiculous and incompetent. It looks like they figure if it's a black person it's "understandable." That's about a millimeter from outright bigotry.