We can't talk about it now, but at some later point when 'Gaza' is supplanted as the apex Omnicase issue, there will be a very interesting conversation to be had about how it was childless adults who were disproportionately emotionally invested in 'the children of Gaza.'
There are all sorts of political dynamics that are only now possible because emotion that was once invested more proximally in the lives of loved ones is now distributed more diffusely into 'politics' in exact proportion to the degree that family and social life have become restricted.
Show more
I’m supportive of international public health aid when it comes to cheap interventions like dispensing HIV and TB and malaria meds. (I am a lib 🤷♂️ .)
However, Kristof is just making everything worse.
First, you can’t hysterically crybully Americans into supporting these programs and trying to do so instead of making a calm, measured case just makes people reactive and oppositional because it’s so obviously a cynical, manipulative tactic.
Second, it’s not our responsibility to fill up anyone’s gas tank. All of these initiatives have to be completely reconsidered and our obligations need to be clearly defined. That Kristof can’t intuit that Americans would oppose filling foreign gas tanks demonstrates just how out of touch he is and that he’s bound to do more harm than good in attempting to propagandize on behalf of international public health.
Third, none of these vignettes meet even the most basic evidentiary standards to support his assertions. Furthermore, this isn’t how it’s done - big programs need to be supported by population level data and Kristof is obviously trying to be emotionally manipulative with anecdotes rather than addressing the policy questions in the right way with the right type of data.
Fourth, it’s lazy and cynical to try to lay this all on Musk. Maybe you shouldn’t have billion dollar ‘managed democracy’ and leftist NGO dark money sinkholes wearing the skin suit of true humanitarian programs. Maybe the people who designed these programs as such deserve a little more (or a lot more) of the blame for intentionally putting them in proximity to legitimate political targets.
Every time I read a half-informed journo trying to do advocacy for foreign health aid I cringe because it’s clear they don’t know what they’re talking about and are making lazy, motivated assertions that are bound to backfire and make things worse. If journos really cared about these issues and weren’t just scrounging for cheap partisan artillery they’d be a lot more carful, thoughtful, and reserved in what they’re arguing.
Show more
This is exactly the type of thing the ultra wealthy should be doing with their time and money. This is how you actually make the world ‘a better place.’
Mark Zuckerberg reveals he's feeding his cows beer and macadamia nuts
“On the ranch, one of my projects is I'm trying to create the highest quality beef in the world”
“It's very low stakes, I’m not selling it but I'm very into the genetics of the cattle. We're trying to figure out how do you make it so that you basically can deliver the highest density diet to them”
“We started growing macadamia trees because that kind of nut is extremely dense and they will eat a lot so they will put on weight and become fat quicker and become delicious”
“The macadamia nuts have a lot of oil so you need to actually roast that. So now we need to design this whole process to roast the nuts so that way you can give them to the cows”
“You want them to eat more. So then it's like how do you get them to eat more? Well it turns out alcohol is great for that because alcohol induces appetite”
“That's actually why very high-end beef, they're fed beer. But okay, what's the right balance of beer versus water? I don't know. Let's let them choose. They get either as much cold beer as they want or as much room temperature water”
“So now we're brewing all this beer and we're putting it out”
Show more
Very funny and quaint that she doesn’t know ‘climate’ is done.
She’s like a Japanese soldier on some remote Pacific island in the 1970s who doesn’t know WWII is over.
Show more
The Color Revolution tactics funded through USAID and designed to destabilize unfriendly governments abroad were eventually turned on the American public.
USAID was also a sinkhole that funneled billions of dollars into leftist NGOs.
Those who put ‘critical humanitarian aid’ in the line of fire in service of illiberal attempts to ‘manage democracy’ are the ones who bear the most responsibility for any harm than comes from these programs ultimately being defunded.
The Enemies List (that Elon sits near the top of) is just a way to offload blame for what in retrospect was extraordinary arrogance and malfeasance.
Show more
By devoting some of its budget to politically-controversial things, thus leaving even its neutral & valuable programs exposed to the risk of reactionary cancellation, USAID administrators have directly caused hundreds of thousands, possibly millions of deaths.
Show more
It bears repeating that the Democratic Party is only being held in place by gerontic sclerosis.
As that inevitably breaks apart ‘progressive politics’ will take the next logical step in its teleology much better captured by the insanity of DSA leftism than it is by any form of sunny, competent technocratic progressivism.
Show more
The entire reason the DSA is surging is that they're willing to take the principles Democrats claim they stand for to their logical conclusion.
I live in Manhattan so it rarely happens but I love walking into a large suburban supermarket.
It’s simultaneously an extraordinary spectacle of wealth, abundance, and prosperity and also ubiquitous and mundane.
Really speaks to what a spectacular success this country is.
Show more
Most often it’s much easier to steal from the future, which is abstract, not yet instantiated, and at a disadvantage in defending itself, than it is from an extant party in the present that has more ability to fight back.
With the rent freeze and kicking the can on pensions, Mamdani is stealing from the future. Whether he recognizes this (given his bottomless entitlement) or not is unclear, but it does seem that one key feature of DSA politics is an ideological vision overdependent on immediate gratification and lacking the capacity to imagine the future in even the most basic way.
Show more
A rent freeze tastes pretty sweet.
Read this amazing paragraph:
‘As I walked through Dolores Park to participate in a trans-led Pride Shabbat service in connection with the trans march, a group of people began screaming at me, ran up to me, surrounded me, and began harassing me, both verbally and physically, including physical contact. They made statements about my ‘Israeli handlers,’ among many other inaccurate, extreme, and vile statements. They were so physically and verbally aggressive that it was impossible for me to safely remain in the park.’
This is the center of Democratic Party politics at the moment. These bizarre spectacles are where the Democratic Party consecrates new orthodoxies and develops policy positions on major issues. This is the ‘brain’ leading Democratic politics, not Hakeem Jeffries or the DNC.
Show more
Senator Wiener’s Statement on Physical Intimidation and Harassment of Political Leaders
SAN FRANCISCO – In two separate incidents this week, Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) was harassed, threatened, and physically intimidated while attending public events to engage with the San Francisco community. Both incidents were sparked by people who had previously targeted Senator Wiener with aggressive behavior in the past. Senator Wiener issued the following statement on the incidents:
”Last night I attended the trans march, as I’ve done each year for the past 22 years since the first march in 2004. I attend each year in solidarity with our trans siblings, who are facing existential threats from right wing extremists, including the President. It has been a deep honor to partner for many years with trans people to advance legislation and budget requests to support the community.
”As I walked through Dolores Park to participate in a trans-led Pride Shabbat service in connection with the trans march, a group of people began screaming at me, ran up to me, surrounded me, and began harassing me, both verbally and physically, including physical contact. They made statements about my ‘Israeli handlers,’ among many other inaccurate, extreme, and vile statements. They were so physically and verbally aggressive that it was impossible for me to safely remain in the park. As a result, I left the park and, for the very first time, did not participate in the trans march.
“This follows an incident Wednesday night at a bar in the Mission where I’d gone to watch a World Cup game. During the game, a man accosted me in a corner of the bar, effectively cornering me and the young women staffers who were with me. He screamed abuse at me and our staff before being ejected by the bar’s employees. After being ejected, the man remained outside the bar, shouting my name and pounding on the side of the bar near where I was sitting for several minutes. The same individual, in December 2023, stalked me on a plane and in an airport, shouting at me about my ‘tainted bloodline.’
”I have no objection whatsoever to anyone disagreeing with me, opposing me, or protesting me. All of that is core to democracy. I also have no issue when people talk to me on the street and ask questions or express opposition. That’s democracy, even when the people engaging in this conduct misrepresent my views.
“But when opposition and disagreement transition to harassment, including cornering me, touching me, or trying to physically bully me out of a public event, that crosses a line. We’re living in a time when violence is all too often threatened or used against people in public life. In San Francisco, we’re better than that.”
Show more
Um…didn’t expect to start my morning with a double shot of Dogwhistling but here we are
I lived in central Philly for a decade, and if I think about why I left, yes it was partly that COVID shuttered public transport which meant I had to get a car and I discovered that parking in central Philly is worse than dental torture. Yes, maybe it was the crime and disorder surge, which at least in my old neighborhood (Broad + South) predated COVID (began around 2018 or so). But the thing that pushed me away the most was the emerging monoculture, the total impossibility of escaping the Same Opinion on every sign, in every conversation, a constant feeling of being horizontally surveilled for wrongthink…terrible for trait openness, in which case the “charming artsy pedestrian friendly old urban core” loses a great deal of its appeal and just becomes claustrophobia inducing.
Moved to suburbs, and these have all the problems I expected them to. But the ambience of neutrality makes it easier to hear one’s own thoughts.
Show more
@daveweigel The fellow who is yelling at Scott Wiener about Gaza has an interesting profession. One of the things he does is he teaches people how to masturbate better.
The retreat from "Musk caused millions of deaths" to "well surely it has caused *some* deaths" is why it's useless to engage with any of this rhetoric
Singal is smart enough to know that these models are based on presumptions unsupported by empirical evidence and that as a result the outcomes and conclusions are predetermined.
Presenting this data this way represents a basic failure in intellectual honesty.
Show more
Stunning midwittery.
Not how this works.
You don’t ‘beat a model with a better model.’
If you’re making these assertions you need empiric evidence, not more refined assumptions, to support your claims.
All of this stuff is ideologically motivated and it should be ignored until there’s robust epidemiological evidence to support the proposed associations.
All of these people put the cart before the horse and the reason they do that is that their first priority is politics and not providing rigorous, clear eyed, meaningful evidence.
Show more
General reminder that "this analysis makes aSsUmPtIoNs!!!" is not a good counterargument.
You have to beat a model with a better model.
What’s the evidence that Musk defunding US AID ‘clearly killed people’?
What is it?
Back of the envelope calculations or actual high quality epidemiology supporting a causal linkage?
Thompson is an ideologue who elides the fact that all these models presume causation, so what we’re dealing with here is just a tautology.
It’s important for people to understand that Thompson’s rhetoric is based on extremely weak evidence with baked in assumptions and that it’s politically motivated and not reflective of any sort of considered analysis of the evidence.
Show more
There are some center-to-right wing accounts I follow that are more offended by the possibility that some public health sources are over-estimating the death count from Musk carelessly destroying US global health programs than by the core fact that Musk really did carelessly destroy US global health (and bragged about it relentlessly) in a way that clearly killed people.
These people know who they are, and they're wrong.
Show more
Bagels aren’t that great. Bagels are fine. Overhyped genre of bread. I eat a lot of bagels and even the best bagel is second tier and undistinguished.
New York people be like “we have the greatest bagels in the world” and you try it and it’s 5/10.
In Argentina, rent freezes destroyed the housing market.
When Milei got rid of the price controls, supply rose by 300%, and rent prices decreased compared to inflation.
But communists are nothing if not absolute idiots who refuse to learn from history.
Show more
7th-year PhD sociology grad student anytime anyone else is able to comfortably pay their rent.