Indeed. Zionists rely on antisemitism to fuel Zionism. It explains their hellbent efforts to conflate Jews with Israel.
Wait, I thought conflating Israel with British Jews was antisemitic?
You don’t speak for Jews, Netanyahu.
Zionism is identity theft in broad daylight.
The Jewish people are not a political nationality. The core project of modern Zionism was precisely to recast an ancient religious people into a modern national collective and transform Jewish identity into a nationality.
Judaism predates Zionism by millennia. Zionism does not get to redefine it.
Show more
🇮🇱 Netanyahu, on who exactly Israel belongs to:
"This is the nation-state of the Jewish people.
Others have rights, but first and foremost, this is OUR nation-state."
So are non-Jewish Israelis just like second-class citizens, then? That's the message from the PM??
They have rights, but it's not THEIR country...
Writer: Michael
Show more
“Jews, Judaism and the Jewish state?!”
Under what rabbinical authority are you acting, Rabbi Mirvis? Making such a disastrous statement and conflating Jews and Judaism with the State of Israel is something no Torah authority would ever entertain.
Show more
I welcomed the opportunity on Friday to meet with the Foreign Secretary, the Rt Hon. Ed Miliband. While we share fervent hopes for a future of peace and security in the Middle East, I explained why I believe the UK Government’s intended sanctions will be counter-productive and even endanger such a vision of peace.
I told the Foreign Secretary that many within the UK Jewish community will view such measures with deep dismay, at a time when the vilification of Jews, Judaism and the Jewish State has already reached unprecedented levels.
The intended policy will not influence Israeli decision-making in the way the Government intends. Instead, it risks inflicting real harm across the region. Given the obvious challenges of defining and implementing such measures, there is a clear danger that they will spiral into a de facto boycott of trade with Israel more broadly, damaging the long-term relationship between our two countries and threatening the livelihoods of tens of thousands of Palestinian workers.
These measures will also disproportionately affect British Jews because of our close religious, family, charitable and educational ties to Israel. Over recent years, we have seen repeatedly that when rhetoric towards Israel escalates, hostility towards Jews is never far behind.
I strongly condemn the reprehensible violence perpetrated against Palestinians by a small number of extremists, yet the UK Government’s proposals will only embolden the tiny minority who support such criminality, while penalising countless others who abhor it.
The stated justification for punishing an ally in this way, is Israel’s long-planned construction of homes in the E1 area. Yet successive peace efforts, from Oslo to Camp David and beyond, have envisaged a final agreement in which this area would remain under Israeli sovereignty.
It is therefore difficult to escape the painful conclusion that domestic political considerations are driving foreign policy, the impact of which is negative both for prospects for peace in the Middle East and for the UK Jewish community.
Show more
You should be concerned about issues that actually affect Jews in the United Kingdom. By falsely creating the impression that a foreign country is somehow intrinsic to Jewish identity, you are endangering the very Jews you claim to represent.
Show more
The JLC is deeply concerned by reports that the government is preparing to announce measures to prohibit or restrict trade with Israeli settlements. Throughout the summer, we have urged the government to avoid irreversible steps that could further damage the UK’s relationship with Israel and have a harmful impact on the UK Jewish community.
We share concerns about settler violence and extremism. However, there is a deeply troubling question of why Israel is being singled out for this form of economic action. If the government proceeds with this approach, it would be the latest in a series of punitive acts taken towards a supposed ally of this country. The harsh reality is none of these actions have had any influence on the situation on the ground. As Israel approaches pivotal elections on 27th October, we urge the government to carefully consider that the only impact of further interventions will be to embolden extremist factions within Israel.
We also urge the government to consider the unintended consequences for our community of the proposals that are being considered. These include the risk of harming the legitimate connection between British Jews and places of great religious, cultural and historic significance, including the Western Wall, Judaism’s holiest site. Broad, untargeted measures may inadvertently become a wider boycott of Israel, giving legitimacy to those who reject Israel's very existence, and placing increased scrutiny on British Jews at a time when antisemitism in the UK is more prevalent and more violent than ever.
Show more
The insistence of Zionists to enmesh Jewish identity with Israel is an existential battle for a nationalist movement that solely rides on shaky legs.
It’s not their concern about antisemitism, or Jews as a whole.
Without exploiting Judaism and blurring the lines between anti-Zionism and antisemitism, they have nothing to work with.
Jews are an ancient religious collective.
Zionism is a modern nationalist movement created to negate the fundamentals of Judaism.
The very notion that we even have the conversation about how one can represent the other shows the complicity of many who claim to “fight antisemitism” but are really here to support a foreign government while exploiting Jews across the globe.
Show more
Anti-Semitism is a hatred of Jews.
Anti-Zionism is a hatred of Israel.
@MarkRuffalo seems to understand the distinction. Why can’t you?
The deflection and projection around this topic is truly astounding. Can Zionists truthfully deny that their institutions and Israeli leadership endanger American Jews by deliberately conflating Jews with Israel?
Show more
Hasan Piker isn’t a Republican-created distraction. He’s a fringe Democrat-created liability.
Blaming Jewish Americans for hatred or violence directed at them is antisemitic.
@hasanthehun is deplorable.
Every Democrat should be able to say that without an asterisk and get back to the issues voters care about most.
I discussed that and more on
@TheStoryFNC:
Show more
The keen observer will notice that those participating in the antisemitism bashing and name calling are not ordinary citizens living in the USA, but Israeli agitators and Zionist institutions.
Now, what do they gain from stirring resentment and enmeshing Jewish identity with Israel?
The answer is obvious:
A win for Israel.
A loss for morally upright Jewish citizens in America.
Don’t fall for it. Do not allow them to succeed.
Show more
The Zionist messaging cycle:
“It is antisemitic to criticize the Israeli state because what you’re really doing is blaming all Jews for Israel’s actions,”
“Which is an attack on all Jews, because all Jews are inextricably tied to Israel”
???
Show more
The people in charge of the “mission” to wrongfully conflate Jews with Israel have always been Zionist institutions and Israel’s leadership.
Pretending to care about Jew hatred while glossing over this obvious hypocrisy is what should be spoken about.
Show more
“Conflating Jews with Israel Is Dangerous – Whether by Antisemites, U.S. Politicians, or the Israeli State”
Amid the outrage over Hasan Piker’s remarks, a Jewish professor of Israel studies argues it’s important to acknowledge what Israel’s actions fuel.
Show more
The pervasive conflation of Judaism and Zionism, and the failure to call out the parties responsible for perpetuating it, is what concerns American Jews…
“the party’s antisemitism problem is veering into dangerous political territory that could eventually cost Democrats Jewish support at the ballot box, to say nothing of the moral implications.”
The Left’s Antisemitism is Still Festering
-
@DavidMDrucker
Show more
Netanyahu has spearheaded the audacious campaign to merge Jewish identity with a foreign country so that Zionists can hide behind “antisemitism” to avoid accountability.
Zionism was never about Jewish safety, but about using Jews to promote Zionism.
Show more
This is almost word-for-word what Hasan Piker is being denounced for saying.
@netanyahu @gidonsaar Your quick reminder that the State of Israel, with Benjamin Netanyahu at its helm, is no representation of Jews or Judaism.
Zionists deemed us Turkish. Now it’s Pakistani. Is that an upgrade?
Zionists trying to own up to the prayers that negate the foundations of Zionism is definitely an interesting idea…
And our “cult” is as much a “cult” as you’d consider Judaism to be one.
"our prayers"?
Your cult didn't exist before the 1930s.
What exactly makes these prayers "yours"?
@netanyahu @gidonsaar Your quick reminder that the State of Israel, with Benjamin Netanyahu at its helm, is no representation of Jews or Judaism.
Now our prayers became an “ancient civilization?” They really have no inkling what Judaism is about.
No, we will not change our ancient civilization to not hurt Palestinian feelings.
Zionisms is a cyclical exploitation of Jewish faith. It is a negation of the inherent principles that constitute our sacred Torah. Zionism denies the fundamental tenets as Exile, Redemptiom but copy pasted verses so Zionism seems “Jewish” all the while exploiting the soul of our faith to substantiate earthly nationalism.
Show more
A bigot makes a fantastic discovery: the love of Zion and Jerusalem is inherent to the indigenous Jewish people. She calls Judaism’s oldest prayers “Zionist,” imagining this to be an indictment of Jews, when in fact she is proving the ancient and unbreakable Jewish bond to Eretz Yisrael (and exposing her own ignorance).
The Lord has sent the Jews many antisemites over the centuries. Mercifully, most of them are just dumb.
Show more
Our prayers for redemption stand in direct contrast to Zionism. We pray for Hashem to restore His Shechinah to the Holy Land and bring final peace to the world. Zionism is not the realization of these prayers, but their denial and denigration.
Show more
Jews have been reciting the zionist Amidah prayer for 2400 years. It was made up by rabbis. They pray it 3 times a day.
The notion that jews are inseparable from zionism is their choice to make and sustain. So far, the vast majority (~90%) continue to support the existence of 'israel' aka zionism. Not surprising when their prayers and religious lives contain zionist teachings.
They can reform the Amidah. Change the outdated and supremacist sections. There's at least six:
- Section 10, 11, and 14 which call for the usurpation of Palestine and displacement of native population.
- Section 1, 12, and 17 which establish a mythical 'spiritual-bloodline' supremacy model and actively target post-Torah divine revelations.
They can always opt to change and exist as a religious community without supremacy or stealing land. They can also just repent. They are actively choosing not to do either.
Show more
So many of the activists fighting antisemitism are deliberately pulling the wool over their eyes and choosing not to see what’s right in front of them.
That is: Israeli leaders using Jews everywhere to promote Zionist immigration plans and pretending that we stand behind their nationalist plans in the Holy Land.
This is not new. Zionists have stirred up, fabricated, and weaponized antisemitism for Jews to “run” to war-ridden Israel and have done everything in their power to silence criticism of the Israeli government by using antisemitism.
They are exploiting Jews, enmeshing our identity with a foreign country, and endangering the lives of Jews everywhere. But all the chatter is directed at the people who actually call this out, not at the people who are perpetrating this abominable behavior.
Time for a rude awakening here.
Show more
The ubiquitous fact that Jews in America are overwhelmingly disassociated from Zionism and do not take an active role in supporting Israel’s leaders is a point that all those so enthusiastically “concerned about” antisemitism conveniently forget to mention.
Show more
Piker is an antisemite. Shouldn’t be hard for any Democrat to condemn him. By name.👇
The Torah is the only core there is to Jewish identity.
And if “Eretz Yisrael” translates as the “State of Israel” for someone, then that begs some very serious questions…
@TorahJews Eretz Yisrael is the core of Jewish identity.