I've been running
@claudeai Duet and
@ChatGPT Dots side-by-side. My impressions:
- Overall takeaway: Dots feels more consumer, Duet feels better for business.
- Both went all in on an iMessage-style UX, and both like to send you a barrage of short messages. This quickly gets overwhelming if you're using it for a lot of things.
- Duet has multiple channels that report into one main channel, like a hybrid of Slack and Grok Bot, which helps me segment work. Dots doesn't have this.
- Teaching either one how you like to work takes a lot of time and manual effort, but once it's set up to your preferences it's great.
- Neither is good yet at tracking and following through on soft commitments, like "I'll get back to you shortly."
- Both underlying models feel great, but it's odd not being able to choose which model I'm using.
- Duet's task list is great in theory but lacking in practice. It doesn't clear finished tasks unless I tell it to, and it misses ones I'd add. Still better than Dots, which has nothing.
- Using Dots in the desktop app is great. Duet has no equivalent, and it's hard to do serious work from my phone.
- Duet's custom instructions carry over into regular Claude, so my personal and work preferences blur together.
This is clearly the tip of the iceberg and I genuinely can't wait to see where this all goes.